World Watch
August 17, 2009 6:41 AM

Marines Walk Afghan Tightrope of Death

By
Lara Logan
Topics
Afghanistan
This Reporter's Notebook was filed by CBS News chief foreign affairs correspondent Lara Logan, embedded with U.S. Marines in Helmand Province, Afghanistan.

(AP Photo/Julie Jacobson)
We were crouched down in a field, the earth steaming with the heat of the sun and the air thick with humidity. Two Marines were kneeling down beside me.
"All we've done since we got here is get blown up," one of them said. And then they started to talk.

On a patrol exactly like this one a few days ago in southern Helmand province, they had been walking along the canal. One of their Marines stepped on a relatively small explosive device hidden in the ground, most likely a landmine.

The problem was, that mine was linked to a bigger explosive device in a deadly daisy chain that did not miss its mark. The Marine who was walking behind was hit by the bigger, secondary explosion.

"We ran as soon as we heard it go off but when we got to the canal the only thing that was there was his body armor. He was nowhere," they told me, "just gone."

So they started to search. Some distance away, they found their friend's arm, his watch still attached.

Pictured above: An Aug. 10, 2009 photo shows Marine Lt. Victoria Sherwood, left, of Woodbury, Conn., waiting with members of a Female Engagement Team for a security detail to take position before making contact with locals in the village of Khwaja Jamal with Golf Company, 2nd Batallion, 3rd Regiment of the 2nd MEB, 2nd MEF in the Helmand Province of Afghanistan.

"I just cannot get that picture out of my head, I keep seeing it, his arm just lying there with his watch. I can't stop seeing it."

It was hours later when they found the rest of him. It would take much longer for the shock to wear off, and the fear to subside.

(CBS)
These Marines know their job. They know the terrain and they're learning about the people pretty fast. They also know their enemy.

In this part of Helmand province, landmines and roadside bombs are the weapon of choice. The roads are literally awash with improvised explosive devices. Entire areas are mined by the Taliban, with hundreds of IEDs.

Just to gain access, Marines are walking a tightrope of death every day.

The Marines in Helmand are part of a U.S. surge some 10,000-troops strong meant to secure Taliban-held parts of the country ahead of this Thursday's presidential elections. Candidates must end their campaigning for that vote tonight, but making many areas safe enough to get out the vote is still very much unfinished business.

The Taliban has enjoyed almost eight years of freedom here. Apart from a few British troops that wandered their way every now and then, much of this province had never seen any significant foreign troop presence — until some 10,000 Marines flooded the area on July 2.

The Marines have pushed the Taliban further south, but there are still areas even they have never been. Hard to imagine that, when the U.S. and NATO have been fighting this war for so long, but completely true.

The terrain in Helmand is as relentless as the enemy. The heat burns into your body, tearing you down bit by bit. There is no shade, no shelter from the sun. The earth soaks up the warmth like an oven and spits it back at you when you come to the end of the day. A clinging, soaking humidity that wraps itself in a sickly blanket around your body.

(CBS)
These are the skinniest Marines I have ever seen, and I've been in some rough places with Marines, like Ramadi in Iraq, where more Americans died than any other part of the country.

But here, I stare in amazement — and some horror — at the uniforms hanging off their lean bodies. There isn't an inch of excess anywhere. Every uniform is worn thin and faded, hanging off wily frames that still manage to haul over a hundred pounds of gear and weapons and patrol for miles.

These Marines have what they need to fight — and just enough to survive.

They don't seem to care. I don't hear them complaining or even talking about it. They make do with what they have and get on with it. It's as if they don't even think about it much anymore.

When you gather around at night, exhausted after a long day, the talk is not of what they will do when they get back. It's of memories and good times back home. It's of the men they have lost, the battles they have fought, the lives they hope to have beyond this place some day.

I think back to the first U.S. soldiers that landed at Bagram Air Base just north of Kabul back in 2001. A young soldier was standing with his weapon as a group of journalists gathered. One of the Afghan soldiers I knew well walked by, and I greeted him with the normal Islamic greeting, "As-Salaam-o-Alaikum," and he responded.

The American soldier stared at me, slightly surprised and nonplussed, not understanding the exchange.

"That's how you greet people in this part of the world," I said to him, "didn't they teach you that before you invaded?"

"No ma'am," he answered politely and looked away, to end the conversation.

What a different Army and Marine Corps the U.S. has today. Many are fluent in the local language where they serve, almost everyone can say a few words. The essential terms for making friends and earning respect — words like hello and thank you, those are second nature.

Here on the base, there is an Afghan soldier who runs a small kiosk, selling things that Marines really want — cigarettes and cold drinks. It's good business for him and welcome respite for the Marines who have access to no comforts here.

But what I enjoy most is watching how they interact. The exchange of words, sometimes a joke, sometimes a deal. The small jibes that are symbolic of sincere affection.

It's not a panacea. It's not a clich? that will save the country. It's just a very human moment in a very inhuman place.


Add a Comment See all 56 Comments
by marinebrother August 30, 2009 1:07 PM EDT
all i know about this crazy war is, my brother is there fighting this war for our country....and all i see on these comments is a bunch of bickering about why we are there and not enough appreciation for our soldiers its ridiculous if u ask me....this story of the tightrope of death is my brothers unit.....and the guy that lost his arm was my brothers bestman in his wedding so think about the facts how do these guys feel bein there riskin there lives each and everyday for us....our children our family and friends ...not none of u are there so i say we control the non sense and show some love to our troops....OOOOOOHHHHHHHRRRRRAAAAHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 29, 2009 4:29 PM EDT
THE DOGS OF WAR HAVE BEEN FIGHTING TOO LONG. IT'S BEEN TWO THOUSAND YEARS + TOO MANY YEARS THE DOGS HAVE BEEN FIGHTING. COMMON/SENSE SHOULD TELL THE MIS/MANAGERS OF THE DOGS OF WAR, THEY HAVE ALREADY FILLED THEIR COFFERS WITH TOO MUCH BLOOD/MONEY, AND WE DON'T NEED MORE COFFINS, BOUGHT WITH THE FATHOMAL COST OF THE BLOOD OF A GENERATION OF INNOCENT AMERICAN YOUTH. OUR CEMETERIES ARE TOO CROUDED NOW. OUR HOSPITALS TOO FULL, WITH AMERICA'S CHILDREN HOME FROM WAR, AND MANY NEVER COMING HOME, NOW ONLY ILLUSIONS FOR US, WHERE ANGELS ONCE PLAYED. WE NEED BETTER SCHOOLS, BETTER CLASS/ROOMS, TO TEACH OUR CHILDREN HOW TO LIVE, NOT HOW TO DIE. DYING DOESN'T NEED TO BE TAUGHT IN WAR, NOR ANY/WHERE ELSE. DYING IS A NORMAL PROCESS OF LIVING, IT WILL COME TO US SOON ENOUGH, WITHOUT OUR HELP. MURDER, IN THE KENNELS OF THE DOGS OF WAR, ARE GHOULS DREAMS, AND OUR NIGHT/MARES. WE KNOW HUMAN/ANIMALS ARE FICTIONAL CHARACTERS, MORE CARNIVORE THAN HUMAN. WE MUST PROVE TO GOD HIS CREATION IS HUMAN. GOD, THE SAINTS AND ALL THE ANGELS IN HEAVEN ARE CRYING, FOR THE SALVATION OF THE HUMAN RACE GOD'S CREATION. HEAVEN IS SO FAR AWAY, AND HELL SO NEAR. EVEN THE DEVIL KEEPS HIS DOORS CLOSED/LOCKED, IN FEAR. BING...
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 22, 2009 12:02 AM EDT
WAR IS SUCH A PAIN IN THE START. IN THE MIDDLE. IN THE BOTTOM. IN EVERY/ONES TOP. WE NEED A PILL TO RELIEVE WAR/PAINS. WE HAVE PLENTY OF LEAD/PILLS TO END PAIN, BUT NO PILL TO END WAR/PAINS. IN THESE MODERN ENLIGHTENED TIMES TODAY, WE SEND OUR GARBAGE TO THE MOON, POLLUTE THE AIR WE BREATH. BUILD LADDERS TO THE STARS. WALK ON WATER. DIG OURSELVES DEEPER INTO THE EARTH LOOKING FOR HELL, AND WE CAN'T INVENT A LITTLE OLE PILL TO END WAR/PAINS. SHAME ON ME. THE MOST INTELLIGENT INVENTOR, PLANNER AND DECIDER ON THIS PLANET EARTH.
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 21, 2009 4:12 PM EDT
MODERN WAR/FARE IS NOT THE CONVENTIONAL WAR/FARE OF THE PAST WHEN ARMIES OF DISCIPLINED SOLDIERS FOUGHT EACH OTHER FACE TO FACE FROM TRENCHES TO FOX HOLES TO OPEN FIELDS IN HAND TO HAND COMBAT. TODAYS WARS ARE GUERRILLA WAR/FARE AND NOTHING IS FAIR. GUERRILLAS ARE INDIVIDUAL RAIDERS WHO HIT AND DISAPPEAR LIKE GHOSTS. REGIMENTED SOLDIERS CAN'T WIN IN GUERRILLA WAR/FARE. GUERRILLA RAIDERS AREN'T SEEN BY A SOLDIER IN COMBAT EXCEPT DEAD. THE GERMAN REGIMENTED ARMIES LEARNED THAT TRUTH IN WWII. AT THAT TIME, GUERRILLAS WERE CALLED UNDER/GROUND FIGHTERS. HIT AND DISAPPEAR SINGLE RAIDERS.
A GHOST ARMY. IT DOESN'T MATTER TODAY IN THE DESERT SANDS OF THE EAST HOW MANY THE ARABIAN/NIGHT GUERRILLAS KILL. THE TERROR ALONE THEY PUT IN THE MINDS OF COMBAT SOLDIERS IS A GUERRILLAS MOST POTENT WEAPON. A SOLDIER WITH ENEMY IMBEDDED FEAR IS NO LONGER A SOLDIER. IN GUERRILLA WAR/FARE THEY USE SUCH BARBARIC INHUMANE TACTICS OVER/THERE, THAT THEY MUST SCARE AND QUESTION EVEN THEM/SELVES. IF THERE BE ANY HUMANITY IN THEM. THE TRUTH CAN BE STRANGER THAN FICTION. WAR IS REAL. AND THE TRUTH WILL SET US FREE...
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 21, 2009 12:16 AM EDT
TO HELL WITH WHO STARTED IT. IT'S BEEN STARTED, GET IT DONE, AND GET THE HELL OUT. IF WE DON'T KNOW HOW TO GET IT DONE, AND GET THE HELL OUT. WHY DID WE LET IT GET STARTED? THAT IS THE QUESTION. TO BE OR NOT TO BE. IF IT BE STARTED AND NOT BE DONE AND GET THE HELL OUT WE MAY NEVER GET OUT. AND MORE COULD BE STARTED, AND NEVER BE DONE. EVEN SHAKESPEARE WOULDNT HAVE THE ANSWER. WE COULD CALL ON CERVANTE.S DON QUIXOTE AND SANCHO, FIGHTING WINDMILLS THAT GO ROUND AND ROUND AND ROUND AND NEVER STOP!...
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 20, 2009 6:05 PM EDT
I DON'T KNOW MUCH ABOUT POLITICS, I DO KNOW A LOT ABOUT POLITICIANS WHO SEND ME INTO WARS TO FREE THE WHOLE WORLD AND KILL ME DOING IT.
IE., A DEMOCRAT (WILSON) SENT US INTO WWI. A REPUBLICAN (HOOVER) SENT US INTO THE '29 DEPRESSION. A DEMOCRAT (ROOSEVELT) GOT US OUT OF THE '29 DEPRESSION AND PUT US INTO WWII. A DEMOCRAT (TRUMAN) STARTED THE NUCLEAR FIREWORKS. A DEMOCRAT (KENNEDY) PROMISED RUSSIA AND CUBA EXTINCTION IF THEY DON'T TALK MORE FRIENDLY. A REPUBLICAN (EISENHOWER)
INRODUCED US TO VIETNAM. A DEMOCRAT (JOHNSON) MADE THINGS WORSE AND IT KILLED HIM DOING IT. A REPUBLICAN (NIXON) MADE VIETNAM SO HOT HE THROUGH IN THE TOWEL AND THE NORTH VIETNAM MONKEYS THROUGH US OUT. WE RUN HOME LIKE SCARED MICE. LOST THOUSANDS OF YOUNG MEN AND SOME WOMEN AND WE CAME HOME WITH LESS THAN WE HAD BEFORE WE GOT OURSELVES IN. PLEASE DON'T TELL ME ABOUT OUR KIND POLITICIANS. CONSERVATIVES CONSERVE OUR MONEY FOR THEMSELVES. LIBERALS ARE LIBERAL WITH OUR MONEY AND CONSEVATIVE WITH THEIRS. AS I MENTIONED IM NOT MUCH ON POLITICS. IF I'M WRONG IN ANYTHING HERE, I STAND TO BE CORRECTED. SINCERELY -- BING...
Reply to this comment
by TNisgoodenoughforme August 19, 2009 1:57 PM EDT
I can't help but cry reading this. My son loves & is so proud to be part of the USMC, & I am proud of him, but this..just breaks a moms heart. I'm praying for each & every Marine. I love you all You are the Best. God please be with them.
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 18, 2009 4:50 PM EDT
THE AFGHAN/IRAQ KILLING FIELDS AREN'T WARS. THEY'RE KILLING FIELDS! OPPOSING ARMIES FIGHT WARS. IN AFGHAN/IRAQ, IT'S TEN MILLION TERMITES AGAINST A FEW HUNDRED YOUNG AMERICAN SOLDIERS WHO SHOULD BE IN SCHOOL LEARNING HUMANE PROFESSIONS HEALING, NOT HOW TO KILL OR BE KILLED. BRING OUR YOUTH HOME, DO IT NOW, WHILE THEY ARE ALIVE. BODY/BAGS AND FLAG/DRAPED COFFINS WE DON'T NEED ON A REGULAR SCHEDULE. THOSE WHO SEND AMERICAN YOUTH TO WARS. I SUGGEST YOU GO OVER THERE AND FIGHT YOUR WARS, AND BRING OUR YOUNG BOYS/GIRLS HOME. NOW IMMEDIATELY! (TRANSPARENCY) THE MODERN WORD FOR TRUTH. HAS BEEN LOST IN SHUFFLING THE OLD DECK OF CARDS. WE HAVE A NEW DECK OF CARDS TODAY. WE'VE BEEN PROMISED OUR SOLDIERS OVER/THERE WILL BE BACK HOME SOON OVER/HERE. WE THE PEOPLE DON'T WANT PROMISES, WE WANT SUBSTANCE, BRING OUR YOUTH HOME. IT'S WORST THEN HELL, TO DIE IN CRUMMY FIELDS, FILTHY MOUNTAINS ALONE, THOUSANDS OF MILES FROM HOME -- BING...
PS: I'VE BEEN TO HELL AND BACK!
Reply to this comment
by PENWEL August 18, 2009 2:32 PM EDT
AMERICA DOESN'T HAVE A FOREIGN POLICY. NEVER HAD ONE. AND SHOULD NEVER HAVE ONE. WE CAN'T AFFORD OUR OWN HEALTH POLICY. WE SHOULDN'T BE BUYING A FOREIGN HEALTH POLICY, WITH THE BLOOD AND SACRIFICE OF A GENERATION OF AMERICAN YOUTH. WAR IS CRUEL, BRUTAL AND CRAZY, BUT IT BRINGS IN THE DOLLAIRS TO THOSE WHO PROFIT BY SELLING A GENERATION OF AMERICAN YOUTH, IN EXCHANGE FOR A FEW BARRELS OF DIRTY OIL. IT KEEPS THE ARABIAN/NIGHTS/HAPPY, SINGING "WE LOVE YOU OVER HERE." BUT WHEN WE'RE FINISHED WITH YOU. GO HOME YANKEE FOOL. THE SAME OLD SONGS, "ARABIAN/NIGHT/MARES." AMERICA SHOULD GO BACK TO THE MARES AND WAGONS, BUT THE "DOGS OF WAR" HAVE ATE ALL THE MARES AND BLOWN AWAY ALL THE WAGONS. I GUESS WE CAN SING OUR OWN SONG NOW. "HAPPY DAYS ARE NEAR AGAIN." NEVER HAPPEN! WE ARE TOO BUSY FALLING OFF JACOBS LADDER TO THE STARS -- BING...
Reply to this comment
by thoriel-howard August 17, 2009 5:37 PM EDT
So let opium-growers folks to fight off Taliban under the command of the military experienced comander-in-chief: Mr. Obama! or Mr. OhLaLa!
Reply to this comment
See all 56 Comments
.

Follow World Watch

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook