Iraqi Justice System Swallows Shoe-Thrower
Randall Joyce is CBS News' Baghdad producer.
Muntader al-Zeidi, the Iraqi journalist who threw his shoes at President Bush, has become a hero in much of the Arab world and a video sensation in the YouTube universe. His assault or protest (pick your own term) has been seen around the world by millions, but al-Zeidi himself is nowhere to be seen.
He has disappeared into an Iraqi legal system that is deeply flawed and, at times, intentionally confusing. If transparency is the standard for a good court system, then Iraq's is the opposite. Opaque doesn't begin to describe it.
Today's proceedings are a good example of just how hard it is to navigate the system. Our crew just returned from Baghdad's Central Court, where al-Zeidi did not appear as expected. His family and a team of defense lawyers hired by his employer, Baghdadiya TV, had been told that his preliminary hearing would take place today, and they arrived at court with the reasonable expectation that they could see the accused and provide legal representation for him.
Instead, they were given a second-hand account of a hearing that had already taken place. The Central Court judge told al-Zeidi's lawyers that one of his colleagues had finished the investigative proceeding against the accused yesterday, in a session that took place in the heavily-fortified Green Zone.
Today's judge announced that al-Zeidi had admitted assaulting President Bush and resisting arrest. According to this account, al-Zeidi said he resisted because he was "nervous and confused" and he added that he would not press charges against security agents who beat him during the incident.
Here's the video again, in case, through some miracle, you've not yet seen it:
The judge said a prosecutor was present at yesterday's hearing and that al-Zeidi had a court-appointed defense attorney. At that hearing al Zeidi is said to have stated that he did not want to be defended by the lawyers who represented Saddam Hussein (they had volunteered).
But that leaves open the possibility that al-Zeidi (at left) will be represented by the lawyers hired by his TV station. The Central Court judge said the decision on whether this case proceeds to trial could come as soon as eight days from now. He stressed that that it is not up to Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki to press charges at this point because the matter is already in the court system. (That preempts any call for al Maliki to drop the charges, of course.)
The charge is assaulting a foreign president, which carries a maximum 15-year sentence, but the judge today indicated there was a wide range of possible sentences.
Al-Zeidi's family was informed at today's hearing that he is being held in a jail in the Green Zone, but when our crew went to that facility they were told he had never been there. So far, no member of his family has seen him and we have no idea of his physical condition.
There is no explanation so far as to why the hearing took place a day earlier than planned at a secret location without the presence of al-Zeidi's legal team or family.
His brother, Dhargam al-Zeidi told the Associated Press that he believes the non-appearance Wednesday suggests his brother was beaten, "and they fear that his appearance could trigger anger at the court."
Whatever al-Zeidi intended with his shoe throwing at that presidential news conference, this incident has opened a window on the Iraqi legal system. For foreigners on the outside looking in, the case is already giving some insight as to what kind of country the U.S. will leave behind.
© 2008 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved. (AP Photo/Bilal Hussein)
He has disappeared into an Iraqi legal system that is deeply flawed and, at times, intentionally confusing. If transparency is the standard for a good court system, then Iraq's is the opposite. Opaque doesn't begin to describe it.
Today's proceedings are a good example of just how hard it is to navigate the system. Our crew just returned from Baghdad's Central Court, where al-Zeidi did not appear as expected. His family and a team of defense lawyers hired by his employer, Baghdadiya TV, had been told that his preliminary hearing would take place today, and they arrived at court with the reasonable expectation that they could see the accused and provide legal representation for him.
Instead, they were given a second-hand account of a hearing that had already taken place. The Central Court judge told al-Zeidi's lawyers that one of his colleagues had finished the investigative proceeding against the accused yesterday, in a session that took place in the heavily-fortified Green Zone.
Today's judge announced that al-Zeidi had admitted assaulting President Bush and resisting arrest. According to this account, al-Zeidi said he resisted because he was "nervous and confused" and he added that he would not press charges against security agents who beat him during the incident.
Here's the video again, in case, through some miracle, you've not yet seen it:
The judge said a prosecutor was present at yesterday's hearing and that al-Zeidi had a court-appointed defense attorney. At that hearing al Zeidi is said to have stated that he did not want to be defended by the lawyers who represented Saddam Hussein (they had volunteered).
(CBS)
The charge is assaulting a foreign president, which carries a maximum 15-year sentence, but the judge today indicated there was a wide range of possible sentences.
Al-Zeidi's family was informed at today's hearing that he is being held in a jail in the Green Zone, but when our crew went to that facility they were told he had never been there. So far, no member of his family has seen him and we have no idea of his physical condition.
There is no explanation so far as to why the hearing took place a day earlier than planned at a secret location without the presence of al-Zeidi's legal team or family.
His brother, Dhargam al-Zeidi told the Associated Press that he believes the non-appearance Wednesday suggests his brother was beaten, "and they fear that his appearance could trigger anger at the court."
Whatever al-Zeidi intended with his shoe throwing at that presidential news conference, this incident has opened a window on the Iraqi legal system. For foreigners on the outside looking in, the case is already giving some insight as to what kind of country the U.S. will leave behind.
Popular on CBSNews.com
- Mexico's drug war 20 Photos
- Graphic video: Man dead in "truly shocking" London attack Play Video
- Muslim hard-liners ID suspect in London attack
- U.K. official: London attack suspects probed before
- Tokyo's rockabilly scene 16 Photos
- Former sex slaves: Osaka mayor should quit
- Man dead in "truly shocking" London attack
- People cling to car in "sidewalk skiing" stunt Play Video
Posted by redbds at 04:14 PM : Dec 17, 2008
Yes, the fact that they "love" Bush is obvious from the support al-Zeidi is getting from the protesters in the streets of Baghdad.
The "fact" that you have spoken to the Iraqi people means little. After all, how many Iraqi people could you have possibly spoken to? As many as have protested in the street recently? I doubt it.
The last part of your last sentence says it all.
Posted by signtwo at 04:56 PM : Dec 17, 2008
Full name Saddam Hussein al-Majid al-Tikriti. AKA ''Great Uncle'', AKA ''Lion of Babylon'', AKA ''Lion of Iraq'', AKA ''Beast of Baghdad''. Saddam translates to ''One Who Confronts''.
Kill tally:
Approaching two million, including between 150,000 and 340,000 Iraqi and between 450,000 and 730,000 Iranian combatants killed during the Iran-Iraq War. An estimated 1,000 Kuwaiti nationals killed following the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. No conclusive figures for the number of Iraqis killed during the Gulf War, with estimates varying from as few as 1,500 to as many as 200,000. Over 100,000 Kurds killed or "disappeared". No reliable figures for the number of Iraqi dissidents and Shia Muslims killed during Hussein''s reign, though estimates put the figure between 60,000 and 150,000. (Mass graves discovered following the US occupation of Iraq in 2003 suggest that the total combined figure for Kurds, Shias and dissidents killed could be as high as 300,000). Approximately 500,000 Iraqi children dead because of international trade sanctions introduced following the Gulf War.
sad....