World Watch
August 19, 2010 11:48 AM

The Most Dangerous Job in Afghanistan - Clearing IED's

By
Terry McCarthy
Topics
Afghanistan

Marines face the hidden dangers of IEDs as they push into the former Taliban stronghold of Safar Bazaar.

As part of our continuing coverage of "Afghanistan: the Road Ahead," - CBS News correspondent Terry McCarthy follows the Third Battalion, First Marines at home, and abroad in Afghanistan.

It is the most dangerous job in Afghanistan - clearing improvised explosive devices, or IEDs, to make roads, paths and buildings safe for Afghans and for the U.S. military.

About three-quarters of all U.S. casualties are caused by IEDs, which also kill and maim large numbers of Afghan civilians. The job is done, primarily, by explosive ordinance disposal (EOD) teams, who are trained to find the bombs, aided by combat engineers, who have the heavy equipment and explosives to clear them away.

This is the story of three such men - Corporal Daniel Greer, with the 4th Combat Engineer Battalion, and Sergeant Johnny Jones and Staff Sergeant Eric Chir, both from the 1st EOD company, attached to the Third Battalion, First Marines - the 3/1. For seven days they worked to find bombs in the Taliban stronghold of Safar Bazaar. Then one blew up unexpectedly.

Watch a Preview of this Story

Afghanistan: The Road Ahead

It was ten minutes before noon when we heard the explosion, just to the south of the compound which the Marines had occupied on the edge of the bazaar. Because of the concentration of IEDs in Safar, the Marines had been ordered to move very slowly, checking every small patch of ground three times with metal detectors, dogs, robots and often on hands and knees with a knife probing under the surface.

Jones and Chir, who worked as a team, and Greer, who worked with the other engineers, had been there since the first day of the offensive - they had lost count of the number of bombs they had found. There were controlled detonations going off two or three times an hour as the engineers or the EOD techs blew up yet another device, rendering it harmless. Everyones' ears were ringing. On this occasion, Greer and Jones and Chir, with several others, were investigating a suspect pile of mortars and tubes at the back of a building barely 50 yards from the compound where the Marines were sleeping.

More of Terry McCarthy's "Thundering Third" Blogs:

In Afghanistan, a Beautiful Desert Goes Boom

A Day in the Life: Wardak, Afghanistan

Preaching to the Corps

Because the local residents were scared of all the explosions going off, the Marines had been using loudspeakers to give them a two minute warning before any controlled detonation, telling them where it was and warning them to keep their distance. But when this particular explosion went off, there had been no loudspeaker warning. Still, initially there was hope that it was a controlled explosion that someone had forgotten to radio in. A sniper on an elevated position at the edge of the compound who could see where the blast had happened was the first to realize this was no controlled explosion, and that it had happened where the engineers and EOD team were working.

"Corpsman" he shouted, calling for a medic (who are universally referred to as "corpsmen" in the Marines). Within moments half a dozen Marines with two stretchers ran across the road and down the back of the building to where the blast had happened.

Captain Nathan Opie, Greer's commanding officer, rushed across and was met by another one of his men who said "they got Greer sir, and they got him pretty bad." Greer was lying on the ground, with a head injury. Near him lay Jones, who had lost both his legs. Chir had taken a lot of shrapnel, but was still able to walk. The three men were brought back to a mobile trauma bay that had been set up in the Marines' compound, where Lieutenant Commander Lanny Littlejohn, a trauma doctor, worked on them until the medevac helicopters arrived - less than 30 minutes after the blast.

A Preview Video of this Story is Embedded Below

When the battalion commander, Lieutenant Colonel Ben Watson, walked into the trauma bay to talk to the men, Jones could only say to him "Sorry I let you down, sir." Watson was speechless. The three men were taken away by helicopter.

The Marines who were left behind were devastated. All knew the tremendous risks these men had taken - repeatedly - over the preceding seven days as they worked to clear the bazaar of bombs. The night before the explosion, Randall Joyce, the CBS producer on site, had casually asked Jones why he did the job he did. "I don't get off on killing people, I'd rather be saving lives," Jones replied.

Some days later we learned that Corporal Greer had died of his injuries. It was a further blow to the Marines, particularly to the Combat Engineers, who had already had 13 men wounded during their deployment. Greer, married with a two-year old son, was a reservist who was a firefighter - he came from Nashville Tennessee, the same town as his commanding officer, Capt Opie. Their wives had socialized together, and Opie, who has a son of the same age, had been talking to him about his family just the day before the explosion. Now he was struggling to come to terms with the loss, and keep the other engineers focused on their mission.

"We can't just take some time off and grieve," said Opie. "We have got to press forward until it is our turn to go home and when we reach that point we will deal with this, and we will figure out how to live with it then. But for now we just have to press forward, and that is what we will do."

That is what Marines do.

Watch A Preview of this Story Below

Add a Comment See all 13 Comments
by Gorilla978 October 25, 2011 8:16 PM EDT
Just an FYI...

EOD assists the Combat Engineers not the other way around..

The route clearance patrols are done by Engineers...if we find something we cannot handle out selves we call EOD (We don't need to nor have we always done this but we are ordered to).

This isn't to suggest EOD isn't capable of doing so but they represent a very very small number of our troops and are not able to do the lions share of the work.
Reply to this comment
by Misalsera October 28, 2010 6:51 PM EDT
I can imagine how upsetting this must be for the families of the injured and fallen, but can we not agree how important it is for the world to see what is actually happening over there, so that people are driven to take action and speak up about their rage, and do something about the situation we are in? I often feel like everyone has forgotten we are at war at all, either in Iraq or Afghanistan. No one of us has all of the answers, and as an employee of CBS, I agree that more tact could have been used in filming, but Terry McCarthy (and others like him, including Sebastien Junger (RESTREPO, see that documentary) are risking their lives, too, to make sure that the world is informed of what our troops are valiantly doing to make things right. I commend their efforts for educating the often very ignorant public about the truth. And let me tell you, this is the truth. My sympathies to those who have lost loved ones, but the American public (and the world) needs this shock factor to buckle down and speak to our congressman, and to our local gov'ts to encourage action in the Pentagon.
Reply to this comment
by constantine32 October 28, 2010 3:22 PM EDT
One thing the author did not include in his article was the important role the Army Route Clearance team served in the bazaar. An article about clearing IEDs should at LEAST mention all of the IED clearance assets that were used during the events in the Safar Bazaar. Also, alot of the footage was put togather to make a story, nevermind the impact that the story might have on some of the Marines' families, careers, and reputation. My thoughts and prayers go out to the families and friends effected by the events at the Safar Bazaar...all Marines, Sailors, and Soldiers involved did an amazing job.
Reply to this comment
by tscottbrown August 26, 2010 9:49 AM EDT
"The Boy with the Bomb Tattoo," did he ever work with the person that alleges that the Oscar "Best Picture of the Year," movie "Hurt Locker" is based on his life? If so, this type of exposure would seem dangerous given his ongoing litigation.
Reply to this comment
by mamohio August 20, 2010 1:18 AM EDT
I would also like to thank CBSnews and especially Terry McCarthy for this report and all previous coverage of the 3/1 Marines in Afghanistan. As a very proud, but very worried mother of a 3/1 Marine deployed in Helmand province, I so greatly appreciate these reports. Without Mr. McCarthy's reports,the family members of the Marines fighting over there wouldn't have any information at all. The media has had a virtual blackout of information on the fighting in Afghanistan. And it seems that for the majority of our fellow U.S. citizens, this has become another forgotten war. Their family members aren't affected, so they don't pay much attention. Since President Bush left office, all those war protestors are silent and the nightly newscasts don't even mention that another soldier or Marine has been killed. Why is that? I think everyone in the country, those for and against the war, should hear and see what our brave men and women fighting this war endure. These reports don't disrespect our military, but hightlight their courage and dedication to our country and their fellow Marines. I hope and pray that God will protect all of our men in Afghanistan and bring them home without injury or harm. My heart is broken for all those families whose loved ones have been seriously injured or killed. I pray that someday you will find some sense of peace. God be with all of you.
Reply to this comment
by mormorkat October 11, 2010 7:52 PM EDT
Dear MamaOhio, I want you to know that to a lot (I hope the vast majority) of Americans, our heroic troops in the Middle East are very much remembered and appreciated. I read somewhere that in London during WWII(?) at 6pm all the church bells would ring, and everything came to a halt so all of London would stop and pray for their troops. (Warning, ?don?t try this at home? ? a Bishop in Phoenix was convicted of a crime for allowing his church?s bells to ring). However, it inspired me to set my cell phone to ring at 6pm every day to remind me to pray for our military and for their families whose sacrifice can be more difficult to bear than the fighting. I hope you find some comfort in the fact that we ARE out here, and we CARE deeply!
The press has been pretty quiet about our people risking their lives for the sake of freedom. I?m thankful for Terry McCarthy?s coverage. It is a difficult line between showing us the extreme sacrifices being made and either offending the family or making an anti-war political statement. I appreciate that he is making the effort. Thanks also for the article on the Marines and their school. Like the US marine who rescued a seriously wounded enemy and carried him to their helicopter under fire, and then told an astonished allied soldier, ?We?re Americans. This is what we do,? these guys give us every reason to be proud to be Americans!
by Jstsktnby August 19, 2010 8:52 PM EDT
Thank you once again Mr. McCarthy for delivering a story that no one else wants to. I find nothing wrong the video footage. People here in the USA need to face what is happening there!

For all of you that are having problems with this video..... how do you know that CBS didn't clear this footage with his family? Lets admit that it isn't that this video is on here..... it's that you don't really want to know the truth about whats going on over there! Face it, our men and women are over there dying everyday! And before any of you jump all over me and tell me I don't know what I'm talking about, I am the proud mother of a Marine with the 3/1 Thundering Third!!!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by AshlandCityGirl August 20, 2010 10:25 AM EDT
I know his family personally and CBS did NOT have permission to show the video footage of Cpl. K. Daniel Greer. In fact his family members have asked repeatedly that their privacy not be invaded while they process their grief. They have been more then generous in allowing the community to welcome him home with a homecoming processional and other such things. Daniel may have been a marine and he may have given the ultimate act of service to his fellow Americans but to have this sprung on a still grieving family, friends, and community as a whole was very bad taste. Please keep in mind that this was a young man with a wife and very young child, not yet even two. The story was enough, the pictures of his last moments.. That is a horrendous diservice to him and his family. Shame on you and all who support this. And as a mother of a fellow Marine.. What would you feel if that was your last image of YOUR child?
by chaseflamz August 19, 2010 7:06 PM EDT
Terry McCarthy - take the footage of the wounded on stretchers off the video! You done great work in showing the valiant efforts of our troops in Afghanistan, but showing the wounded, knowing that one died, is not necessary. Show the bomb crater perhaps, but not the wounded. And if obscurring the pixels of wounds is necessary, then obscure the pixels of their faces too. These young men deserve respect. Figure out the difference between news and personal tragedy, and decide if your Mother would want that on the internet if it were you.
Reply to this comment
by gig76 August 19, 2010 5:34 PM EDT
Thanks to George W Bush we have to be in Afghanistan at this time. If he hadn't had a broken relationship with Osama bin Laden, we wouldn't have issues over 9.11 and over 3,000 persons murdered. Secondly from this family relationship with Bushes, Cheneys and bin Ladens, Osama has won and actually broken America. We have corporations, and businesses laying off folks and taking up the slack with remaining employees, increasing stress in these folks. Soon we will probably have more at work violence from all this increased stress or more suicides from bully.victim issues. Thanks Bush for your lack of leadership in this enormous problem you created by being our Supreme Court appointed President with your evil sidekick Cheney. Worst President ever Bush.Cheney with all your rich folks tax cuts who put the knife into 9.11 ruins to make America a ruin nation under your Power of corruptions and shame.
Reply to this comment
by Jstsktnby August 19, 2010 8:31 PM EDT
HAHAHAHAHAHA! What are you smoking and where have you been? How long will can you blame this on Bush? I suppose in 20 years when something else happens somewhere that will be Bush's fault too!
by stevenandjoyce August 19, 2010 5:29 PM EDT
I agree with the above comment. I am a member of this community. Daniel was a friend of my husbands. His wife is a friend of mine. To have this posted on here for the world to see is sick. How would you feel if your family member or friend was in this video? Have some respect for this family and take this off of the internet. Daniel was such a vital part of our community. To have this as the last memory some of us will have of him is painful and unecessary!!!
Reply to this comment
by jndavis307 August 19, 2010 4:06 PM EDT
As a resident of the community this young, brave marine lived in I think it is a HUGE dishonor to him and his family for this footage to be out there. I myself would have liked to have been warned before seeing him carried out on a stretcher. I did not personally know this hero but I am very upset that this is out there. I could not even begin to know how his family feels. Could you even fathom seeing your loved one that died being carried out on a stretcher? The press is sick, sick beings that seem not to have any type of morals. May God have mercy on your poor souls!
Reply to this comment
See all 13 Comments
.

Follow World Watch

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook