World Watch
June 6, 2010 7:35 PM

On the Ground in Gaza

By
Richard Roth
Topics
In The News

Palestinians wait for coupons to receive monthly food supplies from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency at a warehouse in the Shatie refugee camp in Gaza City.

(Credit: AP Photo)
Crossing from Israel into Gaza at the first Hamas checkpoint - where a guard takes my picture and thumbs through my passport - a notice hangs on the wall, more prominent than the "No Smoking" signs next to it:

Ministry of Interior

To prevent all forms of liquor are confiscated immediately and destroyed and poured out in front of their owners.

Thank you for cooperation

It hadn't been there the last time I visited more than three years ago before the Islamic movement Hamas was elected to govern. Despite the fractured syntax, the general point was clear: alcohol is unwelcome. But the missing word or words left some ambiguity. Precisely what is being prevented? An insult to religious custom? A legal infraction? Drunkenness? And what's the point of the "poured out in front of their owners" part? A demonstration of the guard's integrity? Humiliation of the alcohol-bearing infidel?

Visiting Gaza requires a certain tolerance for ambiguity.

I crossed the border a few days ago with an articulate and well-informed Norwegian aid worker who gave me some context for my visit. I asked him about Israel's claim, backed up by a stack of statistics, that its blockade of Gaza has not created a "humanitarian crisis" in the Palestinian enclave. He said the phrase is an inaccurate description of Gaza's troubles, and that "human crisis" better describes them: There aren't starving children with swollen bellies and primary medical care is adequate, but there's a whole economy that's being strangled, he said, and Gaza is being "undeveloped."

My visit was on Friday, the Sabbath, so in the short window allowed me by Israel's limited opening of the border crossing, I found the streets weren't traffic-jammed and it was easy to move around. The black-uniformed Hamas police seemed relaxed. My Gazan colleague and guide said I didn't have to worry about crime and I could leave just about anything in the car; it wouldn't be stolen. What about physical security, I asked, kidnapping or gun battles or even rocket fire from Israel?

"I think there's no problem," he told me, then qualified that. "I think there's no problem today." That gave me the impression it's a little like the weather, best understood by locals, and I'd stumbled on a good day.

The Feras Market was certainly booming. Locally grown produce is abundant and cheap. A kilo of the most beautiful ripe tomatoes cost 2 shekels, about fifty cents. A dollar buys 15 ears of corn. I couldn't help but think it's great to be a vegetarian in Gaza. However the U.N. calculates that some 70 percent of Gaza's 1.5 million people earn only about a dollar a day.

There's evidence supporting Israel's claim it has relaxed some restrictions on the passage of goods. On the street there were stacks of timber from Finland. There's glass to replace shattered windows. But cement and iron building materials to repair bomb-damaged housing and hospitals are still strictly limited, or banned. Israel's explanation is that those materials could be used to make bombs and rockets.

I saw kids on a donkey cart collecting rubble from bombed buildings. They sell it to be reprocessed into cinderblock. As building materials, they're not very durable, and crumble easily. But apparently building codes aren't too strict.

One section of a market was full of used shoes. A merchant told me that tons of used shoes from Israel have recently poured into Gaza, though an Israeli Defense Forces spokesman I later contacted could not explain why. He said there's never been a ban on exporting used shoes to Gaza.

In any case, the going price for a pair of previously owned Nikes was about $20. New shoes were available, too, for about four times that price. They come from Egypt.

The network of tunnels under the Egyptian border at Rafah keeps Gaza going and everyone knows it. They certainly carry all the stuff industrial society uses and with money there's not much you can't get in Gaza.

Even cars. I met a man with a 2010 Skoda sedan who did the math for me. His new car would've cost him $18,000 in Germany or $30,000 if he bought it on the West Bank. Delivered to him by tunnel from Egypt, he paid $50,000 for it plus a $10,000 licensing fee imposed by Hamas. It's understood the tunnels supply Hamas with at least some of the weapons that Israel's naval blockade is supposed to keep out. The business through the tunnels also provides Hamas with a revenue stream.

There are so many diesel generators on the streets, their din is the national music of Gaza. And the fuels from Egypt are smuggled in, partly because any fuel that does come in from Israel tends to be more expensive.

I met a 36-year-old Gaza-born woman who lived in New Jersey for several years and moved back to Gaza in 2005 when the Israelis moved out. She explained she wanted her four children to know about life where she grew up. She works as a translator and schoolteacher.

Her house has running water, though it's undrinkable. When the electricity stops, which is every day, the water runs only until a tank on the roof runs dry. The Mazola oil and Kellogg's Corn Flakes in her kitchen come from Egypt via the tunnels. The propane gas for her stove comes from Israel but the tanks needed to store it are smuggled in from Egypt.

She can buy shampoo (she pointed out Israelis ban the export to Gaza of shampoo with conditioner; no one seems able to explain this). She can find deodorant and other familiar cosmetics. After sitting in the sun for six days or six weeks at Egypt's border or Israel's while smugglers or bureaucrats decide its fate, it doesn't smell the way it should, she says.

We chatted in the garden outside her Gaza home and imagined an Israeli woman who could be sitting a few miles away in her garden, angry and in fear of rockets from Gaza. She was sympathetic but unimpressed. She said the Israeli rockets and missile fire she'd endured were probably a lot more powerful and frightening. Anyway, she felt she had no power to influence events on either side of the border. And the flotilla of aid ships, she said, wasn't carrying enough aid to make a difference in the lives of most Gazans; she said it was simply carrying a message.

What would be her own message, I asked, about what you need to survive in Gaza? "Ingenuity," she said. "And hope."


Add a Comment
by Void-Master June 7, 2010 5:22 PM EDT
To the author of the article:

You begin paragraph six with, "My visit was on Friday, the Sabbath..."

You reveal your ignorance of the situation. "Sabbath" is a purely Judeo/Christian construct. I assure you, Muslims do not regard their holy day of Friday as "the Sabbath."
Reply to this comment
by Turbidite June 7, 2010 10:05 AM EDT
Nice piece of Israeli propaganda.
Reply to this comment
by tsigili June 7, 2010 9:34 AM EDT
Gaza deserves their situation. They have refused to make peace for 50 yrs. The Palestinians have no one to blame, but their own stubbornness and stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by RespectOthersAlways June 7, 2010 12:51 AM EDT
The human spirit does not rest peacefully in a bed of rejection and humiliation. Humiliation and rejection only breeds greater rebellion in humans. Guaranteed

Peace will come when Palestinians and Jews realize that the life of a Jewish child is neither more nor less important than the life of a Palestinian child.

When reasonable men and women realize the indivisibility of human spirit, the occupation will end, the military jets will stop their devastating and punishing bombings, so will the desperate attacks on innocent Israeli citizens. The transition will be delicate and may even be tenuous for a couple of years. There are no easy answers, choices or alternatives. Until then, men and women on both sides will righteously continue to justify the unjustifiable. What a waste! What a shame!!

The human spirit is indomitable. It always has and always will. That is how Jewish people survived hundreds of years of genocide, pogroms, and the holocaust...and that is why Palestinians persist in the face of all odds and vastly superior weaponry. It is the human spirit folks. To underestimate it, is to arrive at solutions that solve absolutely nothing.

So, let the negotiations begin among equals...learn to appreciate each other?s humanity...It is not too late. Overcome the devastating state of semi-consciousness about the humanity of others...after-all both Jews and Palestinians are Semitic people...children of Abraham.

Your continuing refusal to see, accept, and celebrate each other?s humanity diminishes us all! As members of the human family, we love you both. Expecting us to choose one as more important than the other assaults our sensibilities and violates our core beliefs in fairness. For the children?s sake, let us build a new legacy of real tolerance, appreciation, understanding, and celebration of our common humanity. Thank you.
Reply to this comment
by retm-w June 6, 2010 10:21 PM EDT
Bankersvox

And do you really think the israeli's would let the media interview the children, or see what's taught in their schools, or visit their prisons. Are the israeli's building new christian centers. When are the israeli's going to have an election to elect a pro American Prime Minister, instead of one that's anti American. Would reporters be free to ask anyone anything in israel? Israel even banned and reporters, from covering the last invasion of Gaza. What are were they trying to hide.
Reply to this comment
by bankersvox June 6, 2010 11:54 PM EDT
retm-w: You obviously have a sense of right and wrong, and good questions. The answer is at your own finger tips, even now. Go to the Israeli Press. J-Post, or even better the Harretz Newspaper. Look at the diverse open Society that is Israel. Open to Christians, Muslims, and to critical open exchange of ideas and severe criticism. You may get overwhelmed, as they say get 10 Jews in a room, and you 20 opinions ! In many ways, Is is more open and Democratic than the USA. And yes reporters can go around asking whoever and whatever. AFter the LEb War, there was such criticism from the soldiers concerning leadership and tactics, all reported.
As a Progressive , I support Women rights, child rights, freedoms for speech, all religion, and such. If you are a Progressive too, then you should consider these freedoms and ask, why in the world would you lend any support to the HAMAS, Hezbollah, North Korea, IRAN which denies those FREEDOMS and oppose ISRAEL where these FREEDOMS flurish. IT may be Anti Semetism, I can think of no other answer.
by Seanyke June 7, 2010 3:24 PM EDT
i still think blocking the borders is an cruel act. That shows how ill intentioned the Israeli gov't is. there's nothing close to freedom in Gaza and yet you twisted the words to make it as if the US is less democratic than your women-and-children-murderer country. what a propaganda.
by jankebenzone June 6, 2010 10:18 PM EDT
Did you Israel bashers read this? Israel is treating the palestinians very humanely considering what they have done to the Israelites. Did you read the part where even the Gaza women admits the flottila was just a propaganda message? Do you understand that Israel lets the palestinians in to their country to buy and even work, but that hamas make it difficult for the palestinian to come back into palestine? With any logic, its not hard to see your allegations of Israeli brutality and haeshness are false and unfounded. But then we, the logical, know that terrorists and supporters use lies and propaganda to further their murderous cause. Nothing new, hitler did it, lenin did, stalin did, musolini did ect, ect.
Reply to this comment
by usunus June 6, 2010 9:42 PM EDT
Richard,thanks for telling us that visiting Gaza requires certain tolerance for ambiguity.In other parts of the benighted world that amgiguity is called outrageous propaganda and outright lying.Norwegian aid workers,by the way,have never been famous for offering a truthful picture of the Palestinians or any other recipients of Norwegian aid.
Reply to this comment
by sheila2u-2009 June 6, 2010 8:27 PM EDT
CBS ?CBS ? Perhaps I am wrong, but I can not recall a feature on the poor ISRAEL children who have lived in fear daily and have been maimed by "home made" rockets from GAZA ? I am sure you did this extensive report , right ?
Good question bankers vox
And also hasn't CBS been told of the Helen Thomas comments ? I do not see that story here either ?
Comeon CBS you were always my #1 news site...be fair in your reporting
Reply to this comment
.

Follow World Watch

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook