Upcoming "Silicon Valley" reality show raises questions of authenticity

Bravo reality show "Silicon Valley" (working title).

/ Bravo

(CBS News) Silicon Valley has given birth to some of the greatest technology companies in the world. From Apple to Twitter, San Francisco Bay Area start-ups have been responsible for the computers we use to the social networks we use to over share.

Now, Bravo TV is looking to tell the story of the Silicon Valley startup scene in a new reality show. But, according to the New York Times, Silicon Valley is not thrilled with how it may be depicted.

The show places technology entrepreneurs together in a house in San Francisco. The Times describes the cast as "hard-partying youngsters." There is no mention of writing code or debugging software, which are as essential to a technology startup as oxygen is to humans.

"The show has long been in development with very little input from anyone in Silicon Valley," Randi Zuckerberg, executive producer, said in a Facebook post. "By signing on, I hope to bring a lot of value by advising on how to best capture the spirit of technology and entrepreneurship throughout production."

Zuckerberg is deeply connected to the Silicon Valley story - her brother is co-founder and chief executive officer of Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg, and she was the former marketing director for the company. She hopes that by consulting on the show - which she says was planned before she signed on - she will help capture the "spirit of technology and entrepreneurship throughout production."

However, the tech culture in the Silicon Valley is not exactly known for its glitz and glamour. Engineers in the Bay Area have been known to show up to work in T-shirts and jeans. Leading up to Facebook's initial public offering, Mark Zuckerberg was blasted for wearing a hooded sweatshirt to meetings with investors.

Understandably, Silicon Valley entrepreneurs are concerned with how they will be represented on a reality TV show.

"Popular reality TV is based on personal drama, conflict and entertainment. Programming algorithms doesn't make for good TV. That means Hollywood will have to manufacture and encourage drama," Digg.com co-founder Kevin Rose told CBS News by email.

Rose, who was once dubbed as the most famous man on the Internet, is exactly the type of success story the producers of the show might be looking for. The young entrepreneur has launched or invested in tech start-ups like Digg, Revision3 and Gowalla. Now at age 35, Rose is a partner at Google Ventures.

"I worry that cameras and producers will end up being a distraction for any of the companies involved...we're here to build lasting businesses not become reality TV stars," Rose said.

A start-up that's changing the healthcare industry by advancing electronic medical records technology, Practice Fusion hopes the show will portray the pioneering spirit of tech start-ups in the Silicon Valley.

"I'm sure the show will be entertaining, as Bravo's shows usually are, but what is most exciting about Silicon Valley is the world-changing technology that is being built here," Matt Douglass, co-founder and vice president of engineering, told CBS News.

The San Francisco-based company was singled out by House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi to commemorate the two-year anniversary of the Affordable Care Act.

"We want to serve as inspiration to other technology startups as an example of true progress, regardless of how the Silicon Valley tech community is depicted by television media," Douglas said.

There are several famous Silicon Valley success stories, but they don't quite happen overnight or under one roof. Most tech startups begin with an idea and are built on endless hours of writing code.

Perhaps one of the most symbolic estimations of the reality show "Silicon Valley" comes from Evernote CEO Phil Libin, who heads a company that was a 2008 start-up and has since grown into a company with with an estimated $1 billion valuation.

"I've never heard of it, sorry. Hope Bravo does a good job," Libin told CBS News.

[skeezix06]

Why does anyone watch reality shows? They're garbage.

[gyrocyclist]

"Engineers in the Bay Area have been known to show up to work in T-shirts and jeans"

Chenda, please get a clue. I'm an engineer in the Bay Area (actually, at Livermore National Lab). Jeans and T-shirts are typical for about 50% of my collegues. Except in the summer, when we wear shorts. A far more accurate statement would be, "Engineers in the Bay Area have been known to show up to work in suit and tie. But only if they're giving a presentation to some group or company ... head quartered on the east coast.

I'm no meaning to attack or insult ... but your quoted sentence tells me: hey, stop here. The author really isn't in touch with what he's writing about.

cheer!

[John782011]

So we are going to watch a bunch of nerds discussing the multivariant paths to protect personal information on tablet devices. I see enough of that at work and it ain't pretty. :) As for me I enjoy a nicely written mystery or comedy as I know they are the work of talented people, not just fake angst for the camera.

[hypnotoad72]

And Zuckerberg?

http://www.southernstudies.org/2012/02/facebooks-dubious-social-mission.html

Just another corporate welfare queen.

[hypnotoad72]

From "Undercover Boss" and any other 'reality' show, anybody who thinks they're real or remotely based on real life is a fool. They're all as staged, but the people who studied writing and entertainment lose out in favor of this dumbed down form of television that, ironically, astute sci-fi writers were theorizing decades ago and managed to put examples in their own works... amazingly they got past the censors, but obfuscation is quite a wonderful tool to employ...