November 20, 2007 4:57 PM
- Text
The Right To Bear Re-Writes
Mark Knoller is a White House Correspondent for CBS News.
No wonder the Supreme Court must again decide what the founders really meant in the Second Amendment to the Constitution.
With apologies to James Madison et al, it's just not well-written.
"A well-regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed."
Some say the right to bear arms is being assigned to state militias. Others say it's granted to the citizenry as a whole, and still others have no doubt the founders meant to grant the right to every individual.
If only they wrote in simple declarative sentences, we'd have a better idea what they meant.
It's clear the founders were trying to pack a lot of law into a small number of words. But it gave way to run-on sentences and unwieldy grammar.
If they had written more carefully, we wouldn't be going through legal agony trying to figure out the meaning of it all.
No question they meant well, but frankly, they could have used a good editor.
(AP)
With apologies to James Madison et al, it's just not well-written.
"A well-regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed."
Some say the right to bear arms is being assigned to state militias. Others say it's granted to the citizenry as a whole, and still others have no doubt the founders meant to grant the right to every individual.
If only they wrote in simple declarative sentences, we'd have a better idea what they meant.
It's clear the founders were trying to pack a lot of law into a small number of words. But it gave way to run-on sentences and unwieldy grammar.
If they had written more carefully, we wouldn't be going through legal agony trying to figure out the meaning of it all.
No question they meant well, but frankly, they could have used a good editor.
-
Mark Knoller Mark Knoller is a CBS News White House correspondent.
Follow on Twitter »
1 Comments +
Popular Now in CBS Evening News
- For returning serviceman, a struggle to reconnect
- 5/26: Memorial Day weekend wild weather, slaugher in Syria
- Honoring fallen heroes with thousands of flags
- Wild weather for Memorial Day weekend
- Pessimism amid Egypt presidential election
- Inspiration for the class of 2012
- SpaceX capsule provides supplies for ISS
- On the Road: Planting flags for fallen soldiers
- 5/25: Murder charge in Etan Patz case, strom chaser vacations
- Everest climbers bottlenecked in "death zone"
- 5/24: Etan Patz murder confession, convicted rapist exonerated
- Calif. HS student devises possible cancer cure
- Pope's butler accused of leaking Vatican documents
- Storm-chaser vacations: Nice weather not welcome
- Iran's nuclear program becomes more radioactive
- Company loses millions in NASDAQ glitch
