Macy's flagship's $400M makeover creating stir

Newly-renovated shoe department at the Macy's flagship store in New York's Herald Square / AP Photo/Mary Altaffer

(AP) NEW YORK — A $400 million makeover is giving New York's iconic Macy's store a sleek, new 21st-century style.

And some preservationists aren't happy about it. They see the overhaul of America's biggest department store as scrapping classic Beaux Arts and Art Deco touches in favor of the latest trend in retail design — something like an Apple computer store.

"Macy's has Apple fever," said Theodore Grunewald, a New York preservation activist. "Everyone is jealous of Apple, and thinks the secret to the company's success is this beautiful, elegant minimalist design vocabulary they have. But this is about protection of our heritage."

Macy's reconstruction, to be completed in 2015, will add 100,000 square feet to the 1.1 million square feet of existing retail space. Floor-to-ceiling fabric shrouds areas under renovation. But some sections already have been finished, including the world's largest women's shoe department, which offers 280,000 pairs of shoes — several thousand displayed in white settings.

Macy's spokeswoman Elina Kazan gushes that the store will be a "spectacular place to shop at an iconic New York City destination."

About 20 million shoppers a year visit Ohio-based Macy's flagship store. The building has nine floors of retail space and covers nearly an entire city block, from West 34th Street to West 35th Street, between Seventh Avenue and Broadway.

It is best known as home of the annual Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade and as the setting that inspired the beloved 1947 Christmas film, "Miracle on 34th Street."

Originally constructed in 1902 in the Beaux Arts style, it was expanded in the 1930s with plenty of Art Deco details. Most noticeable was a jazzy, geometric coating of marble, encasing more than 100 columns that soar to the ceilings.

Grunewald said the columns will now be simplified, losing the marble and the ornamental toppings that give the space "its pizazz."

While Macy's has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1978, it has not been given landmark designation, allowing its owners to make architectural changes.

"I was stunned they were doing this, making it look like everywhere else in America when they have a little treasure here," said preservationist Christabel Gough of the Society for the Architecture of the City.

Macy's officials said it was premature to compare the renovation to Apple since it is still a work in progress. They said, too, that the plan actually revives some of the building's distinctive features.

Originally, the interior street floor "was one great retail hall, and Macy's asked us to bring it back as one grand space," said Jay Valgora, chief architect for the renovation. "Macy's asked us to bring back the grandeur of the original store, and whenever there's true historic fabric, to restore it."

Also, the original, ornate entrance on 34th Street will return, and some huge old windows that were painted over have been opened again, lighting a new chocolate-and-champagne cafe. Forty-two of the store's original wooden escalators will stay.

Valgora said the old and the new Macy's will "complement each other" in the same light-filled venue.

"I like it — how organized and open it is," said Rosie Pina, a Manhattan schoolteacher. "Change is good."

Brian Williams, a sports club technician from Queens, joked, "I'm a male, and I don't really care how it looks when I'm shopping."

But standing by the jewelry area near some aging, cream-colored pillars and looking over at a gleaming, snow-white new section, he added: "I like the older better — it feels warmer, more at home."

[Billy_Budd]

I visited Macys yesterday and entered on the Herald SQ entrance. I was expecting a renovation the likes of the lobby of the Empire State building or Grand Central Station since this original Macys is a true New York landmark. What I say inside made me sick to my stomach and shake my head in disbelief. About a third of the original art deco columns had their tops cut off and the columns abruptly met the ceiling which now holds a circle of high tech super bright recessed lamps. The columns look like they were painted a bright white and everything was harsh and painful to my eyes. The new look is something found in a shopping mall in Abu Dhabi not in an historic building in Manhattan. The people behind this "improvement" should be fired including the architects. I will never go to Macy's again after seeing their this vulgar renovation. If the desired affect was suppose to be high end they failed miserably and stole a part of NY history at the same time.

[ssporleder]

Getting rid of the history there is hideous.

They could have just improved lighting (white like Target) and made the shopping expereince more inviting.

In regards to Apple products, yes, they are sleek, but sleek and shiny does not mean any product is exceptional.

[tsigili]

People hate change. They have trouble adjusting to change. Usually change is done for the sake of change, rather than for any real improvement.