CBS News/ December 5, 2011, 11:08 AM

Silicon Valley school bucks high-tech trend

In classrooms across the country, teachers are turning to laptops and even iPads. So you might think the schools in Silicon Valley would be leading that evolution. But one school there has actually banned computers.

The school is the Waldorf School of the Peninsula -- in the heart of high tech country.

IT firm bans email -- will your company be next?

Deborah Newlen, an English teacher at Waldorf, said of tech in the classroom, ""A computer is a good tool, it's a fun toy, it can even be a tutor, but it's not a teacher."

The parents of Waldorf students are some of the most plugged-in.

Kempton Izuno has worked in Silicon Valley for about 25 years. "Just as you wouldn't let a child use a power tool until they were trained on a power tool, there's a time and place for technology," he said.

His wife, Genese Izuno, said, "There's plenty of time for them to learn technology. Plenty of time. I don't think it has a place in the classroom."

At Waldorf, CBS News correspondent Priya David Clemens reports, everything is hands-on, instead of online.

Student Ondine Izuno said she has time with technology -- just at home. "It's just not in the classroom, and I like that," she said.

Waldorf is bucking a national trend of schools going digital, such as Wilbur Wright Middle School in Munster, Ind.

Maureen Stafford, director of instructional programs and assessment at the Munster School District, said officials there feel like pioneers.

Every student at the school has a laptop. And every library desk has a computer.

Stafford said the plugged-in approach helps keep students up-to-date on constantly changing subjects, such as science.

"In those textbooks, they're still reading about the fact that Pluto is a planet," Stafford said. "You look in a science textbook. Pluto is still a planet. "

So it's ironic that while Middle America speeds up, some in Silicon Valley are taking it slow.

Waldorf student Zack Wurtz recalled a recent trip to the Google campus. "It was funny ,because they're so high-tech, and we were learning about them and at the same time," he said, "we weren't using any of their stuff."

When asked if he'd prefer to read a book or an e-reader, Wurtz said, "Pick up a book. The feeling of paper. Being able to underline, write, 'I like this, I don't like this.' You can't do that with your, Kindle thing."

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
6 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cvj says:
Waldorf schools are ... Weird, to say the least!

They are based on the teachings of a Dr. Rudolf Steiner, an Austrian crackpot whose theories were later used by the Nazis to create the whole "Uebermench" crap, which led to the "aryan" master race espoused by Hitler, which in turn led to the camps for "undesirables" etc. and the genocide ?of millions of innocents...

Did "60 Minutes" include that little factoid?

I had 3 grandchildren going through the expensive Waldorf system. We only went once to see a class. The teacher, who follows the child through all the years in the institution, looked and acted as a clone of "Squaky Fromm" - the disciple of Charles Mason! We fled after being asked to join a circle holding hands and dancing around the weird woman who was chanting some weird stuff.

The Waldork kids can not play soccer because the ball is a symbol for a human head!

The women are supposed to wear homespun and carted wool garments!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cvj says:
Waldorf schools are ... Weird, to say the least!

They are based on the teachings of a Dr. Rudolf Steiner, an Austrian crackpot whose theories were later used by the Nazis to create the whole "Uebermench" crap, which led to the "aryan" master race espoused by Hitler, which in turn led to the camps for "undesirables" etc. and the genocide ?of millions of innocents...

Did "60 Minutes" include that little factoid?

I had 3 grandchildren going through the expensive Waldorf system. We only went once to see a class. The teacher, who follows the child through all the years in the institution, looked and acted as a clone of "Squaky Fromm" - the disciple of Charles Mason! We fled after being asked to join a circle holding hands and dancing around the weird woman who was chanting some weird stuff.

The Waldork kids can not play soccer because the ball is a symbol for a human head!

The women are supposed to wear homespun and carted wool garments!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
barbaram99 says:
I can understand the need to teach using what us older people used..I can write simple english by hand but they can't read it. I took penmanship years ago. That is the practise of our letters and how they are printed/written by hand.It was harder for me as a legally blind person with C/P. The school books were in print that I could not see to read. Forget the blackboard. I just sat there.
How is that school to address the needs of sp needs students..Ye don't find a windows based PC in the toy dept--dear Teacher.The school bars Tech,..I can understand the ban on cell phones. In my day it was tape recorders..Blind persons used them, My foster mothers would take my magifiers I needed to read. I learnt the old way sure but it was not blind friendly..i can not read braille. Most blind persons don't. I am 57.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
John782011 says:
Having been at the 21st Century classroom presentation years ago, the most effective technology was a system where the teacher taught math in a regular classroom for four days and then did testing on the 5th using technology. The advantage of the computer there was that the teacher was directed to the students that were having problems and she/he would be able to help the student one of one at the students desk while the others continued on with their assessments. In that case the teacher taught, the computer assessed.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
hawkeyenick says:
Oh look at that, a textbook is wrong/outdated yet again

All you need is wikipedia
reply
John782011 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
There is a reason that wikipedia can not be used as a source in most research papers, it is not resourced prperly, as evidenced by John QUincy Adams being one of this nations forfathers minutes after Ms. Bachmann made her rediculous statement. It is a consensus tool, which I use for personal insight and then use its reference information to find more solid information.