CBS News/ December 6, 2011, 12:20 PM

Arsenic levels in rice draw concern

An elderly woman scoops unpolished rice grains to dramatize the plight of farmers during a protest in front of the presidential palace in in Manila on March 6, 2010. The protesters were demanding more government funds to help the agriculture sector to deal with the effects of the El Nino atmospheric phenomenon which has caused a prolonged dry spells which brought about 11 billion pesos (238.8 million USD) worth in damages to agriculture. AFP PHOTO / JAY DIRECTO (Photo credit should read JAY DIRECTO/AFP/Getty Images)

An elderly woman scoops unpolished rice grains to dramatize the plight of farmers during a protest in front of the presidential palace in in Manila on March 6, 2010. The protesters were demanding more government funds to help the agriculture sector to deal with the effects of the El Nino atmospheric phenomenon which has caused a prolonged dry spells which brought about 11 billion pesos (238.8 million USD) worth in damages to agriculture. AFP PHOTO / JAY DIRECTO (Photo credit should read JAY DIRECTO/AFP/Getty Images) / Getty Images

Since a Consumer Reports study released in recent weeks found 10 percent of store-bought apple and grape juice contained unhealthy levels of the chemical, other foods are now under scrutiny.

Rice, a new study finds, may also contain dangerous levels of arsenic, as well.

Rice is of particular interest because of the way it is grown," medical contributor Dr. Holly Phillips explained on "The Early Show."

"Arsenic is in chemical that's in our soil and rocks naturally," she said. "But for many years in the United States, it was added to our soil in the form of pesticides. That's a more dangerous form of the chemical called inorganic arsenic. It turns the out that the way that rice is grown, in the soil with a lot of water makes it particularly able to soak up arsenic. And so it gets concentrated in the rice and subsequently with eat it."

The Dartmouth study was based on findings of 200 pregnant women; some ate a half-cup of rice a day while others had none. Researchers tested their urine and found women who had a half-cup of rice for just two days had 53 percent more arsenic in their urine than women who didn't, Phillips said.

"It really shows rice can be a source of this chemical," Phillips said. "But we just don't know exactly how much is too much. But we do know it affects fetuses. It can affect pregnant women; it can affect the unborn baby. So, as much as we can avoid it, is a good thing. It's all about how much you're exposed to."

Phillips said you would likely have to have gallons and gallons of rice to really put yourself in danger, but she added, "that doesn't mean we shouldn't follow it closely."

"(The Environmental Protection Agency) regulates how much arsenic is in our drinking water. (The regulation is) 10 parts per billion," Phillips said. "It is not uncommon for rice to have 100 parts per billion or even up to 2,000 parts per billion. Now, in extremely high doses, arsenic can cause cancers, particularly liver cancer, kidney cancer and lung cancer, as well as bladder cancer. It's linked with heart disease, diabetes and some neurological problems in children. But the real question here is how much arsenic are we dealing with? And we don't know that yet. But what this study shows is that we might want to take a closer look at our dietary sources."

There's not a way to avoid arsenic completely, Phillips said, but you can "make a difference," she said, by selecting organic products that are particularly high in arsenic, such as chicken, apple juice -- and rice.

"Even rice cereals and rice milk we need to be careful of," Phillips said. "You should get your water tested, particularly if you have well water. City water is tested automatically. Or, if you have concerns, you can get yourself tested. It's a very easy blood test at the doctor's office."

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
13 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
longtree-2009 says:
is the rice strictly from here in the USA or does it come from abroad as well?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
erasmus111 says:
When it first came out about the arsenic in the apple juice concentrate, I phone our (Canada) Sunrype company. They said that they made all their own concentrate. Then they said "Unless we run out". So I asked where they got it then, and they said they got very little from China, but mentioned a couple of other countries they got it from. Another of those countries was also mentioned has having arsenic.

The problem is also the fact that there is apple juice concentrate in a lot of things, not just juices. And quite often you will find apple juice concentrate in other juices.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
erasmus111 says:
I knew there was a reason I avoided rice. : )
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
FreshxWater says:
To say that Government is bad you'd have to be an idiot or a shill or a Corporate Criminal. As Republicans say, there should be no Government regulations/oversight. Just imagine how polluted the Earth would be, how sick and dying so many people would be!

Why are apples and chicken high in arsenic?
reply
TexasGetsIt replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Government in itself is not bad; however, BIG intrusive, nanny state government IS bad. It takes away our property, it takes away our freedoms, and it takes away our ambition.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
credibility2 says:
...even so-called certified organic products isn't a guarantee, since soil and water, even rain, can't be controlled that might contain arsenic...this is more unnecessary hysteria...
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
TexasGetsIt says:
Reminds me of the studies that concluded if ya drank diet drinks, then you had a slightly higher chance of getting some form of cancer. But only if you consumed over 2000 12oz cans a day, over a period of many years.

More doom and gloom, in the effort to achieve complete control over every aspect of our lives.
reply
Zann-Zel replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Do an experiment - put a rusty nail in a cup of diet coke.
And another one in a cup of regular coke.

Whatever it proves you'll think twice next time you start to put a diet drink into your stomach!
TexasGetsIt replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Ah, but I have the choice (for now). It's absolutely none of your business what I choose to eat or drink. More Diet Dr Pepper please!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kanajune says:
Does anyone proof read these? Good gawd!

"And so it gets concentrated in the rice and subsequently with eat it."

"There's not a way to avoid arsenic completely, Phillips said, but you can "make a difference," she said, by selecting organic products that are particularly high in arsenic, such as chicken, apple juice -- and rice.
reply
FreshxWater replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I was just about to post that too. It seemed to me there should be a "NOT selecting products"
erasmus111 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
No, no one proof reads anything. It's pathetic. You would think that with this being their JOB and being PAID to do it,they would make damn sure everything was right.
See all 13 Comments