Tentative deal reached ending NFL lockout
Furor over call on last play of Green Bay Packers-Seattle Seahawks game Monday night helped propel the two sides in the NFL labor dispute toward settlement
Updated 12:45 a.m. ET
(CBS/AP) NEW YORK — The National Football League and the referees' union reached a tentative contract agreement at midnight Thursday, ending an impasse that began in June when the league locked out the officials and used replacements instead.
"Our officials will be back on the field starting tomorrow (Thursday) night" for the Cleveland Browns-Baltimore Ravens game, Commissioner Roger Goodell said. "We appreciate the commitment of the NFLRA (National Football League Referees Association) in working through the issues to reach this important agreement."
With Goodell at the table, the sides concluded two days of talks with the announcement of a tentative 8-year deal, which must be ratified by 51 percent of the union's 121 members. They plan to vote Friday and Saturday.
"Our Board of Directors has unanimously approved taking this proposed CBA to the membership for a ratification vote," said Scott Green, president of the NFLRA. "We are glad to be getting back on the field for this week's games."
Goodell temporarily lifted the lockout so the regular officials can work Thursday night's Cleveland-Baltimore contest prior to the ratification vote.
The replacements worked the first three weeks of games, triggering a wave of frustration that threatened to disrupt the rest of the season. After a missed call cost the Green Bay Packers a win on a chaotic final play against the Seattle Seahawks in Seattle Monday night, the two sides really got serious.
"Ever since Monday night's disaster of an ending in the Seahawks-Packers game," writes CBSSports.com Senior Blogger Will Brinson, "there has been a push by both the NFL and the locked-out officials to resolve their labor dispute. That push ... resulted in a deal getting done between the league and refs that will end the lockout."
The union was seeking improved salaries, retirement benefits and other logistical issues for the part-time officials. The NFL proposed a pension freeze and a higher 401(k) match, and it wants to hire 21 more officials to improve the quality of officiating. The union fought that, fearing it could lead to a loss of jobs for some of the current officials, as well as a reduction in overall compensation.
The NFL claimed its offers have included annual pay increases that could earn an experienced official more than $200,000 annually by 2018. The NFLRA disputed the value of the proposal, insisting it meant an overall reduction in compensation.
Replacement refs aren't new to the NFL. They worked the first week of games in 2001 before a deal was reached. But those officials came from the highest level of college football; the current replacements do not. Their ability to call fast-moving NFL games drew mounting criticism through Week 3, climaxing last weekend, when ESPN analyst Jon Gruden called their work "tragic and comical."
Those comments came during "Monday Night Football," with Seattle beating Green Bay 14-12 on a desperation pass into the end zone on the final play. Packers safety M.D. Jennings had both hands on the ball in the end zone, and when he fell to the ground in a scrum, both Jennings and Seahawks receiver Golden Tate had their arms on the ball.
The closest official to the play, at the back of the end zone, signaled for the clock to stop, while another official at the sideline ran in and then signaled touchdown.
The NFL said in a statement Tuesday that the touchdown pass should not have been overturned — but acknowledged Tate should have been called for offensive pass interference before the catch. The league also said there was no indisputable evidence to reverse the call made on the field.
That drew even louder howls of outrage. Some coaches, including Miami's Joe Philbin and Cincinnati's Marvin Lewis, tried to restore some calm by instructing players not to speak publicly on the issue.
Fines against two coaches for incidents involving the replacements were handed out Wednesday.
New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick was docked $50,000 for trying to grab an official's arm Sunday to ask for an explanation of a call after his team lost at Baltimore. And Washington offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan was tagged for $25,000 for what the league called "abuse of officials" in the Redskins' loss to Cincinnati on Sunday. Two other coaches, Denver's John Fox and assistant Jack Del Rio, were fined Monday for incidents involving the replacements the previous week.
"I accept the discipline and I apologize for the incident," Belichick said.
Players were in no mood for apologies from anyone.
"I'll probably get in trouble for this, but you have to have competent people," Carolina receiver Steve Smith said. "And if you're incompetent, get them out of there."
Added Rams quarterback Sam Bradford: "I just don't think it's fair to the fans, I don't think it's fair to us as players to go out there and have to deal with that week in and week out. I really hope that they're as close as they say they are."
They were. Finally.
Popular in Sports
- Sergio Garcia apologizes to Tiger Woods for "fried chicken" remark
- NFL's Top 100 Players of All-Time: Debate
- ESPN pulls Hank Williams Jr. over Obama remark
- Phelps wins record 19th Olympic medal
- "Egyptian Popeye" says 31-inch arms all-natural
- Lance Armstrong admits doping to Oprah
- Study: College athletes denied $6.2B over four years
- Ravens survive 49ers, blackout to win Super Bowl
Forty-Four, why is it that GB wields so much power, cause it's no coincidence that after THEIR game gets ruined, THEN the old refs come back.....is it their rise to fame, with rogers and this matthews guy ?? or the fact they are publically owned ? or they have the commissioner's ear and attention ? what is it, do you think ?
I was kind of liking the replacement refs, allowing the players to just play, without calling holding for things like simply blocking....but the interference calls have to be correct, it's TOO important.
___________________________________________________________
They are publically owned, but their share holders actually get nothing out of it apart from a $250 (I think that is the price) piece of paper. They get no say in any team dealings and get no money from profits or anything. Basically it is to say that they have it. They can't trade or sell it either to my knowledge.
Apart from that, we cannot figure it out. I know it is normal to think that the referees are biased against your team, but I have never seen them seem to favor one team more. I though the referees were pretty fair except for when the Lions played GB (both times) and the first time that we played New Orleans last season (NO CB's were doing a lot of holding that was not called all night while our guys were getting all of the calls for the same offense). The second time we played NO had 1 call I disagreed with (1st down after only 9 yards were gained). I also hear that the Giants got screwed by the refs while playing GB last season as well.
As for why, I still do not know. Someone on detroitlions.com put together a little dialogue skit for the real refs, basically them deciding how to "fix" what the replacements had done. That is, fix GB having only one win and NO being winless. It was kind of comical.
______________________________________
On a side note: Not a huge fan of this new layout. Your typing cursor does not move unless you are typing, which can be kind of confusing when you click elsewhere in the post you are typing. It is too plain, and it does not tell you when comments were left. So when I am trying to determine where I am at when looking at new comments in relation to the last one I left, I cannot tell. I have a feeling that this will be like the last time they changed the layout in that it will come down within a few days only to go back up permanently a week or so later.
Forty-Four, I completely agree....there is no guarantee that the regular refs will so much better.....regular refs call too many holding penalties, in my opinion....but the regular refs ARE better at calling interference penalties, CORRECTLY.
it will be interesting to see, the golden boys Green bay get all the calls now
____________________________________________________
I can recall MANY blown/BS calls during both of the Det v GB games last season...just off of the top of my head. I won't list them because several require me to explain why said issues were terrible calls. But if this were a one on one discussion which was face to face (and I had more time) I would gladly mention a few. As a member of detroitlions.com pointed out, "the regular refs make a lot of bad calls as well. Just watch Mike and Mike, it usually makes up the first hour." Paraphrased a little bit, but still.
LOL. Only ten percent of people belong to unions. The other 90 percent don't. Stop blaming unions for government and corporate incompetence.