"Two and a Half Men" is back (and Chuck Lorre talks!)

From left, Jon Cryer, Ashton Kutcher, and Angus T. Jones, May 18, 2011, in New York.

/ AP

(CBS) It's almost like a new show, "Two and Half Men." Except it's not. But the good news is, series stars Jon Cryer and Angus T. Jones seem to like Charlie Sheen's replacement, Ashton Kutcher.

The stars of "Two and a Half Men" are scrutinizing a publicity photo depicting them as a tuxedo-clad trio sharing a vintage microphone.

Ashton Kutcher is in the center of the shot, flanked by Jon Cryer and Angus T. Jones on the other. Charlie Sheen is out of the picture.

Pictures: Ashton Kutcher

"It's nice," offered Cryer, adding a query to Jones: "But that's not your hand, is it? I believe they had too big a black spot there and they photoshopped in a hand."

"That's not my head, is it?" said Kutcher.

Oh, those kidders. But the silliness carries a message: The three actors are a comfortable fit with each other and for the revamped "Two and a Half Men," which returns Sept. 19 for its ninth season, minus the fired Sheen.

Executive producer Chuck Lorre talked with TV Guide about the upcoming season and the decision to cast Kutcher instead of a 40-something actor.

"I was completely convinced that we needed a forty-something co-star who would be a peer to Jon. When I met Ashton, then went back and watched his films and TV work, it was obvious my assumption was wrong. Here was a guy with great comedy instincts, tons of experience, and who is totally fearless -- taking the job proves that. Most importantly, he has a big heart that I thought would be a huge asset in creating a character we could care for."

TV Guide

Lorre and the Warner Bros. studio clashed bitterly with their erratic, hard-partying star before dumping him last March and cutting the season short. The task now is to salvage what has reigned as TV's top-rated comedy.

Kutcher, who carries the weight of replacing Sheen as newly introduced character Walden Schmidt, diligently ticks off reasons the sitcom can remain a hit.

"The series has momentum. It has fans that are built in," he said. "I think the great thing the writers have done is they haven't lost the sensibility of the show. ... It's going to offend people just as much as every episode has offended people."

"Two and a Half Men" accomplished that by trafficking in sexual jokes and innuendo as it detailed the antics of fast-living womanizing cad Charlie Harper (Sheen). More fodder came from his roommates, Charlie's neurotic, divorced brother Alan (Cryer) and young nephew Jake (Jones).

The shake-up has given the show the chance to push the envelope in a new direction: laughing in the face of death, with Sheen's character jettisoned in a fatal accident. Kutcher fills the vacuum playing an Internet genius who is wealthy but unlucky in love and who moves in with Alan and Jake, creating a new buddy triangle. Judy Greer plays the heartbroken Walter's ex.

Producers have been trying, sometimes unsuccessfully, to keep details of the reconstituted show under wraps. Kutcher, who sports a beard in the role, plays it coy when asked about the facial hair.

"You got to ask the writers. We're not allowed to talk about the beard," he says, then relents. "I was being really lazy when I met Chuck and he said, 'I like the beard. Keep the beard."'

Cryer learned about Charlie Harper's demise in an operation worthy of the CIA.

"There was tremendous security during the whole thing and, in fact, no scripts were sent out. You were brought to Warner (Warner Bros. Television), taken into a room with the scripts, left there for half-an-hour by yourself and then you had to leave the script in the room and walk out," he recounted.

Cryer and his co-stars, who have taken a break from production for a joint interview at the studio, say that it's all smooth sailing now.

"We've definitely found our dynamic," Kutcher said. Cryer agreed, lauding the show's writers and his new co-star.

"That came remarkably quick. I think we got a lot of great stuff in the first episode," he said. "The writers got hold of a good dynamic, plus he (Kutcher) changed it in a way that works better than the writers had originally imagined."

Curiosity about how Harper's death is approached and Kutcher's introduction could turn the season debut into "event television," the sort of program that produces buzz and healthy ratings, said analyst Bill Carroll of ad buyer Katz Media.

Ultimately, he suggested, the changes could reinvigorate the long-running comedy and extend its life -- something Sheen, who filed a $100 million lawsuit against the producers over his firing, might not have expected.

"They have a formula. They stay with the formula," Carroll said, which will keep longtime fans watching. The addition of Kutcher, who has cultivated a following with his work on TV ("That '70s Show," "Punk'd"), movies ("No Strings Attached," "Valentine's Day") and avid use of Twitter, will bring new viewers.

"You can't diminish the contribution that Charlie Sheen made to the show but they (producers) have to believe that Kutcher can make his own contribution," Carroll said.

Given the bad blood between Sheen and producers, did Cryer think killing the character seemed more vengeful than funny? The actor, who smartly kept out of the fray engulfing Sheen and their bosses and who said he hasn't heard from Sheen, was diplomatic in his reply.

"The writers had an enormous challenge and you'll see they handled it beautifully. Change is often shocking but it's so true to the show," Cryer said. "And sometimes stuff you don't see coming happens in life." He laughed, ruefully. "And in that respect it was very true to life."

Besides, the show has never wallowed in sentiment, he said.

"That's not the vibe. So everything is treated the same way we've always treated it: In a very crass and vulgar way."

22 Photos

Ashton Kutcher

[Nevanume]

I am a huge Ashton Kutcher fan and was really looking forward to seeing him in his new role on 2 1/2 Men. What a disappointment.

As for Ashton, the character you have written for him is lame.
Who wants to see him play an idiot juvenile dolt? Been there done that. And the plotline that seems to be unfolding doesn't look at all promising. After all the hype, the show is a letdown. You're smart people...couldn't you have figured out another angle? I miss Charlie's biting humor already.
He was one in a million. I was really hoping Ashton's new character would bring a touch of "Charlie Harper" back to the house. And Charlie's death could have been a whole lot more creative and much more hilarious. Instead it was almost handled in a crude, vulgar and dismissive manner. Maybe just a nasty attitude on your end? You could have taken the high road for the sake of the show and the fans. Just sayin'.
I may tune in from time to time to see if it improves, but I'm not the fan I once was.

[StephanieJo19]

The 'surfer boy' naivity of Kutcher is exhausting, and overplayed. To even hint of old Charlie being gay (w/Stamos) means that Lorre is still thinking of the real Charlie sticking it to him. Jesus, I mean Ashton, overacts period, a big bore. He may be able to carry old bag Demi Moore, but he can't carry this show! Even the good-looking broads were replaced w/fugly things! Better glue those ashes together, Lorre, and while you're on you knees doing that, why don't you kiss Sheen's ass to come back. Without him, your show is a goner. I'm still praying this was a bad episode of 'Punk'd' and the whole thing was a scam. Even if it wasn't, clean up your mistake or show's over!!

[jgbog]

I just watched the new show and it stinks. I will not watch it again unless they get Charlie back. It's such a shane they destroyed the show. I'm going to contact the sponsors and let them know what I think about the show they sponsor and boycot their products.

>>> Jim

[rocketjl]

There was a humorous model to the four main characters of the show. I felt the draw to the program began to fade as the young boy began to grow up. His innocence and limited knowledge made for lots of laughter. Now, all grown up and much of the old humor is no longer available. The new show is not going to do well, unless the writers come up with a whole new model that can stand on it's own.

[westerly1]

Personally I thought the show could have carried on without the Sheen character. His womanizing role, I thought, became less the center of the sitcom over time. While Cryer, Jones & the remaining cast became more in the center. The episodes in which Cryer burned down the girl friends house are classic comedy. I look forward to continuation of the show.