By

Michael T. Klare /

TomDispatch/ May 11, 2012, 5:05 PM

Clashes show planet heading into energy overdrive

Ostensibly, the decision was taken in response to a dispute over Israeli payments for Egyptian gas, but all parties involved have interpreted it as part of a drive by Egypt's new government to demonstrate greater distance from the ousted Mubarak regime and his (U.S.-encouraged) policy of cooperation with Israel. The Egyptian-Israeli gas link was one of the most significant outcomes of the 1979 peace treaty between the two countries, and its annulment clearly signals a period of greater discord; it may also cause energy shortages in Israel, especially during peak summer demand periods. On a larger scale, the cutoff suggests a new inclination to use energy (or its denial) as a form of political warfare and coercion.

  • Argentina seizes YPF: On April 16th, Argentina's president, Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, announced that her government would seize a majority stake in YPF, the nation's largest oil company. Under President Kirchner's plans, which she detailed on national television, the government would take a 51 percent controlling stake in YPF, which is now majority-owned by Spain's largest corporation, the energy firm Repsol YPF. The seizure of its Argentinean subsidiary is seen in Madrid (and other European capitals) as a major threat that must now be combated. Spain's foreign minister, Jose Manuel Garc?a Margallo, said that Kirchner's move "broke the climate of cordiality and friendship that presided over relations between Spain and Argentina." Several days later, in what is reported to be only the first of several retaliatory steps, Spain announced that it would stop importing biofuels from Argentina, its principal supplier -- a trade worth nearly $1 billion a year to the Argentineans.

    As in the other conflicts, this clash is driven by many urges, including a powerful strain of nationalism stretching back to the Peronist era, along with Kirchner's apparent desire to boost her standing in the polls. Just as important, however, is Argentina's urge to derive greater economic and political benefit from its energy reserves, which include the world's third-largest deposits of shale gas. While long-term rival Brazil is gaining immense power and prestige from the development of its offshore "pre-salt" petroleum reserves, Argentina has seen its energy production languish. Repsol may not be to blame for this, but many Argentineans evidently believe that, with YPF under government control, it will now be possible to accelerate development of the country's energy endowment, possibly in collaboration with a more aggressive foreign partner like BP or ExxonMobil.
  • Argentina re-ignites the Falklands crisis: At an April 15th-16th Summit of the Americas in Cartagena, Colombia -- the one at which U.S. Secret Service agents were caught fraternizing with prostitutes -- Argentina sought fresh hemispheric condemnation of Britain's continued occupation of the Falkland Islands (called Las Malvinas by the Argentineans). It won strong support from every country present save (predictably) Canada and the United States. Argentina, which says the islands are part of its sovereign territory, has been raising this issue ever since it lost a war over the Falklands in 1982, but has recently stepped up its campaign on several fronts -- denouncing London in numerous international venues and preventing British cruise ships that visit the Falklands from docking in Argentinean harbors. The British have responded by beefing up their military forces in the region and warning the Argentineans to avoid any rash moves.

    When Argentina and the U.K. fought their war over the Falklands, little was at stake save national pride, the stature of the country's respective leaders (Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher vs. an unpopular military junta), and a few sparsely populated islands. Since then, the stakes have risen immeasurably as a result of recent seismic surveys of the waters surrounding the islands that indicated the existence of massive deposits of oil and natural gas. Several UK-based energy firms, including Desire Petroleum and Rockhopper Exploration, have begun off-shore drilling in the area and have reported promising discoveries. Desperate to duplicate Brazil's success in the development of offshore oil and gas, Argentina claims the discoveries lie in its sovereign territory and that the drilling there is illegal; the British, of course, insist that it's their territory. No one knows how this simmering potential crisis will unfold, but a replay of the 1982 war -- this time over energy -- is hardly out of the question.
  • U.S. forces mobilize for war with Iran: Throughout the winter and early spring, it appeared that an armed clash of some sort pitting Iran against Israel and/or the United States was almost inevitable. Neither side seemed prepared to back down on key demands, especially on Iran's nuclear program, and any talk of a compromise solution was deemed unrealistic. Today, however, the risk of war has diminished somewhat -- at least through this election year in the U.S. -- as talks have finally gotten under way between the major powers and Iran, and as both have adopted (slightly) more accommodating stances. In addition, U.S. officials have been tamping down war talk and figures in the Israeli military and intelligence communities have spoken out against rash military actions. However, the Iranians continue to enrich uranium, and leaders on all sides say they are fully prepared to employ force if the peace talks fail.

Click here to continue reading

Michael Klare is a TomDispatch regular, professor of peace and world security studies at Hampshire College and the author, most recently, of "The Race for What's Left: The Global Scramble for the World's Last Resources." To listen to Timothy MacBain's latest Tomcast audio interview in which Klare discusses global energy conflicts, click here or download it to your iPod here. This piece originally appeared on TomDispatch. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author.

2/4

© 2012 TomDispatch
6 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
TimeToEvolve says:
When you let greedy, filthy rich corporations get so big that even national governments bow down before their might, this is what you get. Generally corporations are by nature fascist organizations where you have to listen to the dictator or else and exist only to make money above laws, people and environment.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
prohb says:
No, we are not entering 'energy overdrive'.

We are entering a world, which is getting more and more populated, still addicted to the dwindling resource of fossil fuels. And everyone in the 'second' and 'third' world now wants what we have (because of the infrastructure we created) - gas guzzling independent transportation - commonly known as 'cars'..... among other things petroleum is used for.

We are entering a world of 'energy underdrive'.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
democracy8 says:
While oil is (and may always be) necessary for certain things, e.g., plastic, we COULD significantly REDUCE our consumption of oil by investing in alternate energy sources. I'm sure someone will come on here and make some comment about Solyndra (which they will do more for the purpose of bashing Obama than anything else), but I find it shameful that CHINA is leading the development of the market in alternate energy sources while the US sits on its hands. Part of the reason that the US economy was so prosperous after WWII was that the government DID subsidize/invest in R&D in innovating new technologies.
reply
rightbehind replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
The rest of the planet is running off and leaving us in the muck of big oil.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rightbehind says:
Energy is raining down on top of us. Solar is the way to go.
reply
gwrigley replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You are right on the money! However capitalism will continue exploit oil until there is no more. It's so sad that millions have, and millions more will, die in the fight for oil when we could get it all from the sun. Until we replace for profit corporations with for people corporations nothing will much will change. That's why I support Jerry White for President. I know he won't make much of a showing, but in time the Socialist Equality Party will grow stronger as the greedy corporations pay less and less and send more and more jobs over seas. I pray for the end of this horrible, greedy system that puts individual profit ahead of everything else. The USA is the world leader in unfettered capitalism, and ranks at the bottom of the civilized world in everything of real importance, such as health care for all, living wages, and equality of all citizens. However the USA does rank number one in gun deaths, murders, children shot, and we have 5 times the rate of people incarcerated as the rest of the world. At least we are first in some things.