Warner Bros. wins full rights to Superman

SAN FRANCISCO Warner Bros. has won another significant victory in its epic legal struggle over the commercial rights to the Superman comic franchise.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that the heirs of Superman's co-creator, Jerome Siegel, must abide by a 2001 agreement they made with the studio. The ruling overturns a trial judge's decision in 2008 siding with the Siegel heirs in their attempts to expand their commercial control.

36 Photos

Auction of Hollywood memorabilia

It's the second significant victory for the studio in its years-long battle for control of Superman. Three months ago, heirs for the other co-creator, Joseph Shuster, also lost their legal bid to regain a share of Superman's copyright.

Taken together, Warner Bros. now enjoys complete control of the Superman franchise. It plans to release the movie "Man of Steel" this summer.

[Local-Man]

Actually, This is good news if you are a fan of the character. While the creators deserve some credit for the original creation, most of the key elements of Superman were created by DC Comics later. (For example, originally, Superman did not fly, wasn't nearly as fast or as strong, and didn't have any of the classic villains.) Also, it is DC Comics that has built Superman into the most iconic comic book hero in the world.

Since DC fully owns the character, it will be free to use the character. If the heirs of the creators had won, they could have demanded huge licensing fees or refused to allow use of parts of Superman's mythos, such as his Kryptonian origin.

[jnostromo]

Wonderful, they have freedom to now destroy another American Icon...Get ready for the "dark" Superman

[tsigili]

Big business is always the winner over the little guy.