Much of $60B from U.S. to rebuild Iraq wasted, special auditor's final report to Congress shows

AP

WASHINGTON Ten years and $60 billion in American taxpayer funds later, Iraq is still so unstable and broken that even its leaders question whether U.S. efforts to rebuild the war-torn nation were worth the cost.

In his final report to Congress, Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction Stuart Bowen's conclusion was all too clear: Since the invasion a decade ago this month, the U.S. has spent too much money in Iraq for too few results.

The reconstruction effort "grew to a size much larger than was ever anticipated," Bowen told The Associated Press in a preview of his last audit of U.S. funds spent in Iraq, to be released Wednesday. "Not enough was accomplished for the size of the funds expended."

In interviews with Bowen, Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki said the U.S. funding "could have brought great change in Iraq" but fell short too often. "There was misspending of money," said al-Maliki, a Shiite Muslim whose sect makes up about 60 percent of Iraq's population.

Iraqi Parliament Speaker Osama al-Nujaifi, the country's top Sunni Muslim official, told auditors that the rebuilding efforts "had unfavorable outcomes in general."

"You think if you throw money at a problem, you can fix it," Kurdish government official Qubad Talabani, son of Iraqi president Jalal Talabani, told auditors. "It was just not strategic thinking."

The abysmal Iraq results forecast what could happen in Afghanistan, where U.S. taxpayers have so far spent $90 billion in reconstruction projects during a 12-year military campaign that is slated to end, for the most part, in 2014.

Shortly after the March 2003 invasion, Congress set up a $2.4 billion fund to help ease the sting of war for Iraqis. It aimed to rebuild Iraq's water and electricity systems; provide food, health care and governance for its people; and take care of those who were forced from their homes in the fighting. Less than six months later, President George W. Bush asked for $20 billion more to further stabilize Iraq and help turn it into an ally that could gain economic independence and reap global investments.

To date, the U.S. has spent more than $60 billion in reconstruction grants to help Iraq get back on its feet after the country was broken by more than two decades of war, sanctions and dictatorship. That works out to about $15 million a day.

And yet Iraq's government is rife with corruption and infighting. Baghdad's streets are still cowed by near-daily deadly bombings. A quarter of the country's 31 million population lives in poverty, and few have reliable electricity and clean water.

Overall, including all military and diplomatic costs and other aid, the U.S. has spent at least $767 billion since the American-led invasion, according to the Congressional Budget Office. National Priorities Project, a U.S. research group that analyzes federal data, estimated the cost at $811 billion, noting that some funds are still being spent on ongoing projects.

Sen. Susan Collins, a member of the Senate committee that oversees U.S. funding, said the Bush administration should have agreed to give the reconstruction money to Iraq as a loan in 2003 instead as an outright gift.

"It's been an extraordinarily disappointing effort and, largely, a failed program," Collins, R-Maine, said in an interview Tuesday. "I believe, had the money been structured as a loan in the first place, that we would have seen a far more responsible approach to how the money was used, and lower levels of corruption in far fewer ways."

In numerous interviews with Iraqi and U.S. officials, and though multiple examples of thwarted or defrauded projects, Bowen's report laid bare a trail of waste, including:

--In Iraq's eastern Diyala province, a crossroads for Shiite militias, Sunni insurgents and Kurdish squatters, the U.S. began building a 3,600-bed prison in 2004 but abandoned the project after three years to flee a surge in violence. The half-completed Khan Bani Sa'ad Correctional Facility cost American taxpayers $40 million but sits in rubble, and Iraqi Justice Ministry officials say they have no plans to ever finish or use it.

--Subcontractors for Anham LLC, based in Vienna, Va., overcharged the U.S. government thousands of dollars for supplies, including $900 for a control switch valued at $7.05 and $80 for a piece of pipe that costs $1.41. Anham was hired to maintain and operate warehouses and supply centers near Baghdad's international airport and the Persian Gulf port at Umm Qasr.

--A $108 million wastewater treatment center in the city of Fallujah, a former al Qaeda stronghold in western Iraq, will have taken eight years longer to build than planned when it is completed in 2014 and will only service 9,000 homes. Iraqi officials must provide an additional $87 million to hook up most of the rest of the city, or 25,000 additional homes.

--After blowing up the al-Fatah bridge in north-central Iraq during the invasion and severing a crucial oil and gas pipeline, U.S. officials decided to try to rebuild the pipeline under the Tigris River, at a cost of $75 million. A geological study predicted the project might fail, and it did: Eventually, the bridge and pipelines were repaired at an additional cost of $29 million.

--A widespread ring of fraud led by a former U.S. Army officer resulted in tens of millions of dollars in kickbacks and the criminal convictions of 22 people connected to government contracts for bottled water and other supplies at the Iraqi reconstruction program's headquarters at Camp Arifjan, Kuwait.

• no previous page
• next

1/2

[sciline]

That's like having a business for Ten(10) Years and nobody ever stopping by to buy anything. And you never noticed this. But on year Ten(10) you decided to ask yourself: "I wonder what's going on here"? Come on!
Another case of "Who Suffers; Who Pays; Who Profits"! Just follow the money!

[sciline]

Headline: "Much of $60B from US to 'rebuild'[?] Iraq wasted."

What do THEY mean by "MUCH"? THEY must have meant to say "ALL"!

[sciline]

It appears that we show as little concern for where our Money is going as we do as to where our Environment is going!

[sciline]

Headline: "Ten years and $60 Billion in American taxpayer funds later, Iraq is still so unstable and broken that even its leaders question whether U.S. efforts to rebuild the war-torn nation were worth the cost."

TEN(10)YEARS, you say? TEN YEARS before anyone checked to see what these folks were doing with our $60,000,000.00? That's $6,000,000 a year!
Certainly we could have sent someone over there, besides our Troops, to visually check on the New Schools, etc., that they were supposed to be building and/or Audit just where the hell our money was going, or, at the very least, into whose pockets it was going!
It sounds like we are as incompetent at checking to see where our money was going as they were at spending it!
None so blind as those being paid not to see!

[w_roos]

I guess $60B doesn't buy as many rose petals to throw at one's feet as it used to.

[TimeToEvolve]

This is such a Duh! What does anyone think was the reason for invading Iraq. No WMD, no Al Quada, nothing but the typical imperialist invasion by Wall Street using the taxpayer funded military.

This is so obvious, I can't believe we put up with it.

[knsn_for_cmn_sense]

Thats what the government likes to do.

Blow up and throw away money.

Now it is just padding some corrupt middle eastern politicians pocket. Or several corrupt middle eastern politicians pocket.

[TimeToEvolve]

The whole Iraq war was about Wall Street corporations stealing. They got a good return for buying the corrupt politicians, mostly Republicon.

[enwr77]

As if we needed a report to tell us what was already known. Yet it is a wasted report as with all financial crimes in this country, nothing will be done about it. It is the norm as those in government allow the robbery from our country. Wait until someone is bold enough to produce a report of the monies wasted on national security.

[Rocket_USA]

Wait until we get the report from Afganastan. Can you say another $60 billion wasted?

[FOX_PARROTS_LIE]

"Much of $60B from U.S. to rebuild Iraq wasted, special auditor's final report to Congress shows"



Surprise....surprise....surprise......that cheney's folly would have enriched the WAR Profiteers at the expense of making Iraq even more unstable -- proving that the big winner of the U.S.'s worse military blunder in history, is Iran!

[Priestly-Badtouch]

Remember the missing pallets of cash in $100 bills? Estimates vary, but as much as $20B disappeared in this form.

Billions. In Cash. The war criminal Cheney continues to laugh at the gullibility of his supporters.