Australian court OKs cigarette logo ban
In this computer-generated image provided by the Minister for Health and Ageing of Australia, proposed cigarette packaging stripped of all logos and replaced with graphic images that tobacco companies in Australia will be forced to use is shown. / AP Photo/Minister for Health and Ageing
(AP) CANBERRA, Australia - Australia's highest court upheld the world's toughest law on cigarette promotion on Wednesday despite protests from tobacco companies that argued the value of their trademarks will be destroyed under new rules that will strip all logos from cigarette packs.
The decision by the High Court means that starting in December, tobacco companies will no longer be able to display their distinctive colors, brand designs and logos on cigarette packs. The packs will instead come in a uniformly drab shade of olive and feature graphic health warnings and images of cancer-riddled mouths, blinded eyeballs and sickly children. The government hopes the new packs will make smoking as unglamorous as possible.
"This is a victory for all those families who have lost someone to a tobacco-related illness. For anyone who has ever lost someone, this is for you," Attorney General Nicola Roxon and Health Minister Tanya Plibersek said in a joint statement. "No longer when a smoker pulls out a packet of cigarettes will that packet be a mobile billboard."
British American Tobacco, Philip Morris International, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International are worried that the law will set a global precedent that could slash billions of dollars from the values of their brands. They challenged the new rules on the grounds that they violate intellectual property rights and devalue their trademarks.
The cigarette makers argued that the government would unfairly benefit from the law by using cigarette packs as a platform to promote its own message, without compensating the tobacco companies. Australia's constitution says the government can only acquire the property of others on "just terms."
The court, which ordered the tobacco companies to pay the government's legal fees, withheld its reasons for the judgment on Wednesday. They'll be released later this year.
Australia's graphic tobacco warning labels
British American Tobacco spokesman Scott McIntyre said the company was disappointed in the court's decision, but would comply with the law.
"Although the (law) passed the constitutional test, it's still a bad law that will only benefit organized crime groups which sell illegal tobacco on our streets," McIntyre said in a statement. "... The illegal cigarette black market will grow further when all packs look the same and are easier to copy."
Imperial Tobacco echoed that argument.
"Plain packaging will simply provide counterfeiters with a road map," Imperial Tobacco spokeswoman Sonia Stewart said in a statement. "The legislation will make the counterfeiters' job both cheaper and easier by mandating exactly how a pack must look."
Australia's health minister dismissed those claims, saying there are still measures to prevent counterfeiting, such as the use of alphanumeric codes on legitimate cigarette packs.
"There are all sorts of counterfeiting operations around the world," Plibersek told reporters. "The fact that this packaging looks like this now doesn't make it easier to counterfeit."
Jonathan Liberman, director of the McCabe Center for Law and Cancer, told reporters outside the court that the ruling would inspire other countries to take the same measures against tobacco companies.
"It shows to everybody that the only way to deal with tobacco industry's claims, saber rattling and legal threats is to stare them down in court," he said.
"It's a fantastic decision for public health in Australia," he added.
Popular on CBSNews.com
-
One year after Afghan massacre, villagers work with U.S. troops One year after U.S. Staff Sgt. Robert Bales was accused of slaughtering 16 Afghan civilians, the villagers in the town where the atrocity took place have joined the U.S. special forces stationed there to assist in the fight against the Taliban.
- Basement living in China 6 Photos
- 50th Paris Air Show 13 Photos
- Italy top court cites "erotic game" hypothesis in Knox case
- Widespread protests in Brazil 22 Photos
- 100,000 line streets of Brazil to protest corruption
- Torrential rain devastates Northern India 15 Photos
- Hungary indicts 98-year-old for Nazi war crimes
- Reports that Turkish cops arresting protest suspects
I am simply one who believes what is good for the goose, is good for the gander. If they feel the need to label their cigarettes with such disgusting ads, why not label EVERYTHING that causes deaths of their citizens with the same philosophy?
Oh, I see. You must be a non smoking, drink your socks off party girl who can't walk 2 feet, drive 2 feet or wait 2 seconds without a cell phone in one hand and a drink in the other, aren't you?
I'm guessing you might have even been the female, for lack of a better term, who was in front of me at Academy Sports who thought so much of her chit chat, she couldn't find enough manners buried within herself to hang up and TALK to the cashier while she was actually trying to conduct business.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. You might believe putting those pictures on cell phones and drink labels are a bad idea, but I just bet you also think abortion is another term for contraceptive.
Call me what you want but the truth still remains I AM right.
How about helping the graphic design industry out by FINALLY getting the morgue photos of botched up surgeries and deaths from drug overdoses and misprescribed prescriptions on the walls of the hospitals and doctors offices??!!!
OR how about, pictures of people with their heads bashed in on helmets for all their motorcycle riders???
BETTER YET!!! PUT BASHED UP, CUT UP, MUTILATED DEAD BODIES FROM ALL THOSE CAR WRECKS ON CELL PHONES AS SCREEN SAVERS!!! What better way to make people THINK before they TEXT and DRIVE!!
YEEEEEHHHAAAHHH AUSTRALIA!! Congratulations on saving so many lives by creating so much more garbage!!