Egypt court rules entire parliament illegally elected, orders body to dissolve after unconstitutional vote

A protestor stands on a barricade of barbed wire as Egyptian military police stand guard during a protest against presidential candidate Ahmed Shafiq outside the Supreme Constitutional Court on June 14, 2012, in Cairo, Egypt. / Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images

Updated 5:44 p.m. ET

(CBS/AP) CAIRO - Egypt's highest court on Thursday ordered the country's Islamist-dominated parliament dissolved and ruled that the last prime minister to serve under Hosni Mubarak could stay in the presidential race, twin blows to the Muslim Brotherhood that could sweep away its political gains since Mubarak's ouster 16 months ago.

The rulings by the Supreme Constitutional Court, whose judges are Mubarak appointees, escalated the power struggle between the Brotherhood and the military, which stepped in to rule after Mubarak's fall. The decisions tip the contest dramatically in favor of the ruling generals, robbing the Brotherhood of its power base in parliament and boosting Ahmad Shafiq, the former Mubarak prime minister who many see as the military's favorite in the presidential contest against the Brotherhood's candidate.

Senior Muslim Brotherhood leader and lawmaker Mohammed el-Beltagy said the rulings amounted to a "full-fledged coup."

"This is the Egypt that Shafiq and the military council want and which I will not accept no matter how dear the price is," he wrote on his Facebook page.

Special Section: The Arab Spring
Egypt authorizes military to arrest civilians
Lawyer: Mubarak fears prison doctors want him dead

The Brotherhood and liberal and leftist activists who backed last year's revolution against Mubarak accused the military of using the constitutional court as a proxy to preserve the hold of the ousted leader's authoritarian regime and the generals over the country. Many of them were vowing new street protests.

In the United States, White House spokesman Jay Carney told CBS Radio News correspondent Mark Knoller the Obama administration was reviewing the court's decision.

"We continue to believe Egypt's transition must continue and that Egypt is made stronger and more stable by a successful transition to democracy," Carney said in an email statement. "Egypt has an enduring role as a security partner and leader in promoting regional stability and we look forward to continuing our close cooperation with the new government."

The ruling means that new elections will have to be held to form a new parliament. In the last election, held over three months starting in November, the Brotherhood came out the big winners, grabbing nearly half the seats. Ultraconservative Islamists known as Salafis won another 20 percent. In the months that followed, the Brotherhood tried to translate those gains into governing power but was repeatedly stymied by the military's grip.

Egyptian presidential runoff candidate Ahmed Shafiq is greeted by a supporter after attending a press conference in Cairo June 8, 2012.

/ AP Photo

On Saturday and Sunday, Shafiq goes head-to-head against the Brotherhood's candidate, Mohammed Morsi, in the presidential run-off. The race has already deeply polarized the country. The anti-Shafiq camp views him as an extension of Mubarak's authoritarian regime. The anti-Morsi camp fears he and the Brotherhood will turn Egypt into an Islamic state and curtail freedoms if he wins.

In its decisions Thursday, the Supreme Constitutional Court ruled that a third of the legislature was elected illegally. As a result, it says in its explanation of the ruling, "the makeup of the entire chamber is illegal and, consequently, it does not legally stand."

The explanation was carried by Egypt's official news agency and confirmed to The Associated Press by one of the court's judges, Maher Sami Youssef.

The law governing the parliamentary elections was ruled unconstitutional by a lower court because it breached the principle of equality when it allowed party members to contest a third of seats set aside for independents. The remaining two thirds were contested by party slates.

In a separate ruling, the court said Shafiq could stay in the presidential race, rejecting a law passed by parliament last month that barred prominent figures from the old regime from running for office.

Defenders of the law argued that after a revolution aimed at removing Mubarak's rule, parliament had a right to prevent regime members from returning to power. Opponents of the law called it political revenge targeting Shafiq. The court said the law was not based on "objective grounds" and was discriminatory, violating "the principle of equality."

"This historic ruling sends the message that the era of score-settling and tailor-made law is over," a vigorous Shafiq told supporters gathered in a rally.

The rulings throw Egypt deeper into uncertainty and threaten more instability after more than a year of tumultuous transition under the military's rule. Throughout, opponents of the military have accused it of seeking to preserve its influence over politics even after its promised handover of power to the elected president by July 1. They also believe it wants to largely keep the bases of Mubarak's rule in place, including many figures from his now dissolved ruling party.

At the same time, there has been widespread public dissatisfaction with the Islamist-led parliament, which many criticized as ineffective.

The Brotherhood's popularity had declined since the legislative elections because of moves that critics saw as attempts to monopolize the political scene and advance its own power. It angered liberals, leftists and secular Egyptians when it and other Islamists tried to dominate a parliament-created panel tasked with writing the next constitution. The panel was dissolved by court order, and a new one had yet to be appointed.

• no previous page
• next

1/2

[stormerF69]

Does this mean we can claw back the 1.5 billion Hillary and Obama gave to Egypt????????????????

[smittyc]

Another Afghanistan has been born. The Muslim brotherhood took 45% of the vote and 20% went to Islamic fundamentalist, a more conservative group than the Muslim brotherhood. If those numbers are accurate, civil war will be the outcome. Now Hilary Clinton has picked a fight with the Russians.

[Molly-Pchr]

Anyone else notice the networks' news coverage, the "Gee, poor people of Egypt" attitude, showing the men in the street saying their dream is dying? Kumbaya. How quickly we forget. Weren't they raping news reporters there last year? C'mon, please.

[flexsf]

I will never complain about a court decision that comes down against religious fundamentalists, Christian or Muslim. Religious fundamentalists are sexist zealots that must be exterminated.

[smittyc]

Egypt is not the U.S., Shariah law was voted in by 65% of the Egyptians. Those odds are not good for the 35%, we should have minded our own business, and left Mubarak in control. At least there was stability, they are now facing a civil war. That means a lot of dead people which is not a good outcome.

[Molly-Pchr]

LOL. Sexism is bad but wanting to exterminate people is okay. Listening to yourself? Probably not, and I don't blame you.

[raymailhot]

Rather then the remarks on how American politics resembles this mess, people please read up on french history! They are setting themselves up for a new kind of government! Something a little more totalitarian then what they have seen. Out of the chaos will come some real evil!

[llamafarmero]

dem astroturfers...

[Jaylah54100]

Sounds a lot like our own Supreme Court effectively re-writing the US Constitution and announcing GWB "the winner."

[raymailhot]

Because you wanted a local Florida democrat party to declare the next president?

[realtimecoffee]

In case you want the truth:
http://articles.cnn.com/2001-04-04/politics/florida.recount.01_1_ballots-without-presidential-votes-undercounted-ballots-miami-herald-and-usa?_s=PM:ALLPOLITICS

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=121753&page=1

[melpol12]

Loud Egyptian mobs are made up of mediocre minds; the loudest are the most ignorant. The new Egyptian dictator must protect the privileged and gifted, without them the nation would be left with a blind half-witted rabble. Only a few thousand Egyptians are born leaders, the rest must accept Mother Nature's limitations.

[cbsnews_viewer]

Time to take you medication.

[Ourdoc1]

When did the RepukliCON SCOTUS move to Egypt? Sounds like something they would pull. We all know if the next election is close they will find in Romney's favor, thats a given the way they stole the election for the nutcase Bush II.

[realtimecoffee]

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=121753&page=1

[infantryman1968]

Egypt court rules entire parliament illegally elected, orders body to dissolve after unconstitutional vote


LOL!


Obama and his followers put the Muslim Brotherhood into power in Egypt.

The Irony.

[raymailhot]

I believe you have stirred up a loony liberal!

[sdguero]

Sounds like the majority of the Egyptian people want to institute an Islamic, faith based, government. Those in charge don't want that to happen. Why? I'm not sure, but I'd guess it's a combination of power hoarding and a fear that the country will become the next Iran if the Muslim brotherhood is allowed to take over.

If I was a well to do Egyptian, I'd leave the country.

[cube4hire]

Elections are important and a stalwart of democracy but can also be a curse. Hitler was elected and that turned to be tragic for the German people and Europe. All governments should be secular in my opinion. If Egypt becomes the next Iran with it's huge population it was be a ominous for the entire region and Egyptian people.

[Molly-Pchr]

cube-Please. Hitler was NOT elected chancellor. He was named Chancellor by then President von Hindenburg.