CBS/AP/ February 2, 2012, 10:45 AM

Egypt army, police blamed for soccer bloodshed

CAIRO - A narrow stadium exit turned into a death trap. Crowds of Egyptian soccer fans fleeing supporters of the opposing team armed with knives, clubs and stones rushed into the corridor, only to be crushed against a locked gate, their rivals attacking from behind, survivors and witnesses said.

The result was the world's worst soccer violence in 15 years, with at least 74 people crushed, suffocated or stabbed to death.

Many Egyptians, from the public to lawmakers, on Thursday blamed the police and the country's ruling military for failing to prevent the rioting the night before in the Mediterranean coastal city of Port Said.

Prime Minister Kamal el-Ganzouri, in an emergency parliamentary session, announced he has dissolved the Egyptian Soccer Federation's board and referred its members for questioning by prosecutors about the violence. He also said the governor of Port Said province and the area's police chief have resigned.

CBS News correspondent Mark Phillips reports the police on duty at the Port Said game are even being accused by some of colluding in the violence. They seemed to do nothing to prevent the home team fans from flooding onto the field, and there may be an explanation in Egypt's recent history.

The ultras, backers of Al-Ahly club, were at the forefront of violent protests a year ago that led to the collapse of the police force, and in more recent months, they have clashed with soldiers during rallies demanding an end to military rule.

Now, conspiracy theories suggesting the police and army might have allowed the Ultras to come under attack in Port Said as retaliation for their involvement in the uprising are sweeping across Egypt, and making the security forces the focus of even greater public anger.

In an emergency session, Parliament Speaker Saad el-Katatni, of the Muslim Brotherhood, accused security authorities of hesitating to act, putting "the revolution in danger."

"This is a complete crime," said Abbas Mekhimar, head of parliament's defense committee. "This is part of the scenario of fueling chaos against Egypt."

Major soccer stadium disasters throughout history

Protests and a march on the Interior Ministry were planned Thursday against the police force over the violence. In the morning, dozens of angry protesters sealed off Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the 18-day uprising that toppled Mubarak, while others blocked the street in front of the nearby state TV building in preparation for the rallies.

The riot at the stadium in Port Said erupted when fans of the local team, Al-Masry, stormed the field following a rare 3-1 win against Al-Ahly, one of Egypt's most popular clubs.

Al-Masry supporters, armed with knives, sticks and stones, chased Al-Ahly players and fans, who ran toward the exits and up the stands to escape, according to witnesses.

Lines of riot police in the stadium largely did nothing to intervene, witnesses said. At one point, the stadium lights went out, plunging it into darkness. At the time, the TV sportscaster announcing the match said authorities shut them off to "calm the situation."

"We were surprised the police let them in that easy. The numbers were huge," said Ahmed Ghaffar, one of the visiting Al-Ahly fans at the stadium.

As many Al-Ahly fans crowded into the corridor leading out of the stadium, they were trapped, with the doors at the other end locked.

"Layers of people" were "stuck over each other because there was no other exit," Ghaffar tweeted on Thursday. "We were between two choices, either death coming from behind us, or the closed doors."

He said Al-Masry fans beat Al-Ahly fans who fell on the floor.


1/2

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
18 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
credibility2 says:
The only ones to blame for this are those that participated in the melee.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
keote_poet says:
I went to see a riot, and a soccer game broke out...
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
dmcar2000 says:
I see the rest of the world has caught on to the good ole USA way of blaming someone else for the actions of criminals.
reply
Swiftright replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
So If a thug kills your wife while a police officer watches and doesn't intervene you would consider the officer blameless?

They're not saying the police are responsible for actually killing the people. But the police basically stood there and watched nearly a hundred people get killed.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
lloydbest1 says:
"CBS News correspondent Mark Phillips reports the police on duty at the Port Said game are even being accused by some of colluding in the violence."

It appears that it wasn't just collusion. Al Jazeera claims that some cops actively participated in the mass assualt. Locked gates at exit points also suggest some kind of plan or at minimum, sheer carelessness.

At this point I can't back up my opinion, but I believe this "riot" was planned days or even weeks in advance and given the awesome amount and kind of weaponery brought into the stadium by the "hooligans" there was intent to commit mayhem long before the game even started.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
sjosephm says:
Brings new meaning to the winners "rubbing it in".

Can we stop blaming everyone and everything else and take some responsibility for our own actions... finally.
reply
g-h-o-s-t-13 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
agree, the blame rests solely on the shoulders of the idiots unable to show restraint at a "game/competition" and is totally unaccceptable
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cwong99 says:
What can the police do if they are outnumbered 1 to 100 against former revolutionaries? Probably. Nothing.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
KnowerseekerReturns says:
I agree with this guy: ' "This was unbelievable," he said. "We were supposed to be celebrating, not killing people. We defeated Al-Ahly, something I saw twice only in my lifetime. All the people were happy. Nobody expected this." '. I think that the thugs with weapons were not Al-Masry fans, but simply thugs with weapons that the police/military gathered up to use to attack the Ultras.
reply
enlightenu replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I agree, that this was preplanned by the police is blatantly obvious. Also, who else would have allowed all those weapons into the stadium to begin with?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
sirmarion-2009 says:
SO do not blame the Thugs and murders,blame the police. Where do they think they live in N.J. or L.A.?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
brutomaz says:
How about a little blame for the rioters themselves?
reply
livingtxlife replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Absolutely ridiculous! Hopefully they've got good PR for the police there.
askagain replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Perfectly stated. We live in a world whetre people do not accept responsibility for their actions. It is always the fault of the other guy.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Liberty_in_MA says:
So much for "Arab Spring", huh?
I like the way this story suggest that the Police are to blame and NOT the hooligans with the knives, rocks and stones.
reply
See all 18 Comments