Nearly 2 in 3 hate crimes unreported, Justice Department study finds

Judy and Dennis Shepard, parents of the late Matthew Shepard, become emotional while speaking at the Matthew Shepard Memorial Bench dedication on Sept. 27, 2008, in Laramie, Wyo. / AP Photo/Laramie Boomerang - Andy Carpenean

WASHINGTON Despite growing awareness of hate crimes, the share of those crimes reported to police has fallen in recent years as more victims of violent attacks express doubt that police can or will help.

Nearly 2 of 3 hate crimes go unreported to police, the Justice Department's Bureau of Justice Statistics reported Thursday. For the years 2003-06, 46 percent of hate crimes were reported to police. But more recently, for 2007-11, just 35 percent were reported.

There was an increase in the percentage of victims of violent hate crimes who didn't report the crime because they believed the police could not or would not help, from 14 percent in 2003-06 to 24 percent in 2007-11, the bureau said.

• Federalizing hate crime laws
• The battle against hate crimes
• Rally for hate crime laws

"It's shocking to see that much of an increase in the feeling of futility that hate crime victims are apparently experiencing," Jason Marsden, the executive director of the Matthew Shepard Foundation, said in an interview. Shepard, a gay college student, was killed in a 1998 attack that police said was motivated in part by his sexual orientation. His parents started the foundation.

Hate groups are becoming increasingly violent, which raises the possibility that victims are afraid to report the acts to police out of fear of reprisal, said Jim Bueermann, president of the Police Foundation, the nation's oldest police research organization.

Among various studies that point to rising violence in hate crimes, the statistics bureau found a growing percentage of violent hate crimes as opposed to property crimes. Violence accounted for 84 percent of the hate crimes during 2003-06 but rose to 92 percent during 2007-11. This comes as the Southern Poverty Law Center reports that it has identified more than 1,000 organized hate groups in each of the last three years, compared with 600 to 700 such groups in the period 2000-02.

The decline in reporting disclosed in the statistics bureau's new study comes despite increasing attention paid to the subject of hate crime by police and community groups.

"What's surprising about this is that knowledge of hate crimes is far more prevalent across the country than it ever has been at any time in our history," Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum, said in an interview. The forum is a Washington police research organization.

Congress has defined a hate crime as a criminal offense motivated by bias against a race, religion, disability, ethnic origin or sexual orientation.

The data in the latest report comes primarily from the National Crime Victimization Survey, which has been collecting information on crimes motivated by hate since 2003. The statistics bureau is able to gauge the percentage of crimes that go unreported to police because its victimization survey is based on a large, representative sample of Americans interviewed annually by the Census Bureau about their experiences with crime and responses to it.

The Police Foundation's Bueermann said there is an increased sensitivity on the part of police to the devastating nature of hate crime.

"I certainly saw that in my career," said Bueermann, who spent 33 years as a Southern California police officer, 13 of them as a police chief.

"If those statistics are accurate, then police chiefs have to focus on the issue of why the members of their communities believe that the police aren't willing to investigate," Bueermann said. "I think this underscores the importance of police chiefs repeating these messages over and over and over" urging victims to report hate crimes.

The study found during 2007-11 an estimated annual average of 259,700 hate crimes against people age 12 or older.

The percentage of hate crimes motivated by religious bias more than doubled between 2003-06 and 2007-11 — from 10 percent to 21 percent. Meanwhile, the percentage motivated by racial bias dropped from 63 percent to 54 percent.

In the years 2007-11, whites, blacks and Hispanics had similar rates of violent hate crime victimization.

[MaxK341]

Leave it up to a government bureaucrat to dream up these stupid oxy-moron phrases. All crime is hate crime. You don't abuse, injure or kill someone that you love. Just call the crime what it is. Was it assualt? Was it Murder? Then punish according to the severity of the misdeed.

[realtimecoffee]

words of wisdom...

[bobw101]

That bureaucrat has got to do something all day, if not for nonsense like this he would be playing angry birds all day.

[Dirty_Water]

How in the world can you accurately count "hate crimes" that are not reported. This is a worthless waste of statistics.

[realtimecoffee]

Imagine if they were worried about unreported crime period. The statistics would dwarf the IRS code.

[HM8432]

The problem isn't people not reporting 'hate' crimes, it's authorities cherry-picking what THEY consider to be a hate crime. A White 7-year old girl in my town was attacked and had her school lunch money stolen by two adult Black men, and they were charged with simple assault and battery. Now, imagine if it was a Black girl attacked by two White guys...everyone knows what the resulting charge would be...stop the hypocracy.

[endpcnow]

Hundreds of examples of black mob violence against Whites or Jews NEVER get labeled as hate crimes. Some still deny this problem exists. (Curiously, the same people who deny the problem are always the first to explain it away.) Officials almost always label the attacks "random." There is nothing random about a consistent pattern of group violence by blacks against non-blacks. If the attacks were random, then the victims would be randomly distributed, and there would be numerous black victims of flash mobs. These "flash mobs" represent a social problem, the victims are not chosen randomly, and if whites were committing similar attacks against non-whites, we would be in an officially declared racial crisis. The welfare state fosters hordes of selfish and undisciplined young people, their cruel and ignorant culture drives them to violence, and when a pattern of racial violence emerges, a politically correct media does its best to conceal that pattern from public view.

[KennethKrieger]

I do not believe this story. The liberal media is RACE BAITING again. You people have cried wolf one time too many. Tomorrow there will be a gobal warming story with the name switched to climate change since they can not prove man made global warming. You never try to make Obama create jobs. You want equal pay for no effort so we all end up poor. Kenneth Krieger Cape Coral, Florida

[bilrobi1]

Racism is absoluley entrenched in the fabric of this country. The only way to really do anything about is to recognize the problem. It can't be minimized by saying it's because people over react. Racism exist. Incidents happen every day. and your not wrong that some racial incidents are motivated by a