Military sexual assault victims testify before Congress

WASHINGTON Sgt. Rebecca Havrilla, the lone female member of a bomb squad in eastern Afghanistan, was allegedly raped days before she was supposed to go back to the United States.

"The rape," she said, "was the 'ironic icing on the cake.'"

What started in basic training in January of 2004 with sexual jokes, innuendoes and simulated sexual play escalated to groping, slapping, harassment and ultimately ended with a rape before she left Afghanistan in September 2009, she said.

Havrilla's story gets worse before it gets better: she ran into her alleged rapist at a shop on Fort Leonard Wood; says she was told by a military chaplain that "it must have been God's will for her to be raped"; and says a friend found pictures of the attack on a pornography website.

Havrilla finally reported her case only to have it dismissed by her military commanders. On Wednesday, however, Havrilla is testifying in front of the U.S. Senate Committee on Armed Services Subcommittee on Personnel and share her story.

Havrilla's story is one of many and the statistics are grim: an estimated 19,000 service members experience sexual assault a year, according to the Department of Defense's Sexual Assault Prevention and Response Office (SAPRO). Eighty percent of military sexual assaults have gone unreported. In 2011, a mere 3,192 cases were reported but only 1,516 of those cases were considered actionable.

Prosecution rates are even lower: a reported 8 percent of cases actually went to trial, and of those, many accused sex offenders walked free, some even returning to the military. The Department of Defense also does not maintain a military sex offender registry.

Critics attribute these statistics to the military legal system, also referred to as the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). In this system, sexual assault reporting and prosecution is not subject to civilian law but to an internal justice system. "Command discretion," a key element of the military legal system, leaves adjudication in the hands of military commanders, leaving open the potential for serious conflicts of interest.

"Even if you felt uncomfortable about something, you learned pretty quickly not to say anything, or to express any type of indignation or you'd be targeted for more," Havrilla told CBS News of the widespread fear of retaliation for reporting a sexual assault.

The system was arguably necessary in the old days, when troops were isolated and you needed a certain hierarchy and level of power right there on the ground, explained attorney, Susan Burke. Burke's firm based out of Washington D.C. specializes in claims arising from rape, sexual assault, and sexual harassment.

"The reality is that most of our allies -- United Kingdom, Canada, Australia -- they've modernized their system of military justice. We are just behind; we haven't done it yet," Burke said.

Wednesday's Senate hearing is the first on sexual assault in the military in 10 years. After an eerily similar string of sexual assault allegations, the chairman of the Senate Armed Service Committee requested a review of the Air Force in 2003. While the House, Senate and Department of Defense Inspector General's office all made recommendations for reform, many weren't acted on.

The buildup to the hearing on Wednesday has been slow moving. It began with a civil lawsuit in 2011 against former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld and former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, filed by 28 service members, represented by Susan Burke, who say they were sexually assaulted. The thread of graphic details from case to case throughout the complaint paints a vivid picture of the widespread culture of sexual violence. The case was dismissed at the end of 2011, with the court ruling it had no jurisdiction over military legal matters.

More recently has been the scandal at Lackland Air Force Base in Texas, in which 62 female trainees came forward alleging that they were sexually assaulted or harassed by their training instructors.

A case currently at the center of media attention that has been one of the the focuses of the hearing on Wednesday, is the overturning of the sexual assault conviction of Lt. Col. James Wilkerson, a pilot and inspector general of the 31st Fighter Wing at Aviano Air Base in Italy. Wilkerson was found guilty of sexual assault and sentenced by a jury but Lt. Gen. Craig A. Franklin soon thereafter made the decision to overturn the conviction, allowing a free Wilkerson to be reinstated in the Air force. Following an uproar from some lawmakers, newly installed Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel ordered a review of the case and the UCMJ as well.

Anu Bhagwati, the executive director and co-founder of Service Women's Action Network (SWAN), was the first witness at the hearing on Wednesday. Bhagwati believes that reform should be two-pronged. Military commanders must have zero say in deciding whether or not a case goes to trial and military personnel needs to have access to civil courts so that victims can sue for damages.

"There is no recourse at the end of the day," Bhagwati told CBS News, "You can't just increase prosecution."

Col. Martha McSally, a retired United States Air Force Colonel who served for 26 years, has been an advocate for the reform of military culture, which she says may present a difficult work environment for women, depending on the leadership environment. McSally was in a unique position, being a woman in the "chain of command," and only once had to handle a sexual assault complaint when she was an acting commander, a statistic she attributes to her leadership. McSally is unsure if replacing the military justice system is the solution, as she saw the need for the system in order to foster the covenant between a superior and subordinate.

"You are responsible as the commander to set the climate. Am I going to set a climate of inappropriate jokes or am I going to set a climate that we are all on a team together?" McSally told CBS News. "It's about a climate of professionalism and respect. It's not just about the perpetrators but also facilitators."

"Bad leadership, good leadership -- it makes a big difference," Rebekah Havrilla told us, echoing McSally's sentiments.

"The people that were supposed to help me, take care of me, protect me, and I them - it goes both ways -- were the ones that caused the most harm. They were the ones that did the most damage."

[Dibit]

This is a terrific article...courageous and well-written. Thank you, CBS, for reporting so well on such an important topic. You didn't "gladify" it, your writer told it like it is. Wish it had all been longer.

Please keep on top of the topic... important for us all. Bravo

[sy2502]

CMIXXX why do you have such a problem with criminals being brought to justice? Why do you keep denying anything happens, blaming the victims, and defending the criminals? Are you one of them? What's your interest in protecting them exactly?

[wowmanfarout]

TIME TO SEPERATE THE BOYS FROM THE GIRLS. MAKE SURE THEY DON'T
SHARE THE SAME FOX HOLE OR LIVING QUARTERS.
STOP SETTING THE YOUNG MEN UP WITH TEMPTATION.

[sy2502]

Sure, blame the victim!
Jackass.

[bilrobi1]

It's not likely they really use "fox holes" anymore. Women have served in other military's for years. Take Israel for instance. The question is why is it happening in our military. People "get tempted" every day. It doesn't mean they act on it.

[PourpaixPourpaix]

What does America expect? You take a young person full of idealistic values taught over more than a decade, and put that young person in uniform, only to systematically destroy each and every decent value and replace them with a criminal attitude ready to murder and plunder on command. Wise women stay away from the military, because that's their best shot at avoiding contact with the criminal elements. Perhaps if America doesn't want our young men behaving this way, we should go back to making American soldiers instead of Nazis, or using soldiers to actually just defend America instead of pressing them into service as mafia hit men.

[samXXkiley]

coucou,
this kind of practice is common in all institutions in U.S.A, including the military, they often go unnoticed. The complaints are often late, victims fear the judgments of others, but also afraid of reprisals from their attackers, not to mention the slowness and impunity of justice, factors that discourage victims.
"au revoir"

[neologistic]

cmixxx: Your level of deep denial speaks volumes. Got issues much? Can't wait to hear what else is in your reality: Holocaust denial, happy, well-treated slaves who later loved Jim Crow, or mean little green men talking to you via your tin foil helmet?

[busterthedawgy]

cmixxx is a mess. He must fear women a great deal.

[imnho]

The general involed should testify before congress and ih he does not have a good reason for his actions, he should be demoted to private and discharged from the service

[MilitaryRetiree]

After having spent more than 25 years in two branches of the military, I found out that in most cases, a person didn have to commit rape. And in my job where I was required to be 'in the know' of sexual assault cases, very, very few of the accusations were with merit. Usually it was because of a poor performance rating that the women accused someone of 'assaulting' them. Yes, some of the cases were valid accusations, but in a lot of the cases, the women just wanted the attention. My advice would be "don't believe everything you hear".

[Ulgnud]

Absolutely right. A report must be investigated with all due diligence. Just because she says something happened does not mean that it did. There is such a thing as proof. There are too many career destroying witch hunts started by a simple unproved accusation. Remember the Duke lacrosse team or the Anita Hill accusation? Remember, burden of proof is on the accuser. Read your constitution.

[Sea_Captain]

19 years and nothing's changed. From my own mother asking me "what had I done to provoke the man," to the squadron commander who accused me of hurting unit morale by filing a complaint with Social Actions.

Women are as much at fault as men for perpetuating the culture of silence. As I returned from a military psychiatric hospital after attempting suicide... a female major in the squadron told me "she hoped I'd enjoyed my vacation."

With all due respect, I seriously doubt that Col McSally only had one incident of sexual assault during her time as a commander. Unless her "acting" commander gig only lasted a month, or she was in charge of a unit of 10 or less people.

Silence is insidious. Once the silence is broken... the real harassment begins. I hope Sgt Havrilla has a better support system in place than I did.

[mcp-ag]

If you're interested in sharing your story, please email me at [e-mail].

[sy2502]

It's repulsive and contemptible that we hold people in the military, people we pay with our own money, and trust with our national safety to infinitely lower professional standards than the average employee. I am sick of having my tax payer money go to a bunch of sexist pigs ol' boys club who even have the nerve to lay claim to "honor", "integrity", and "courage". It sure takes honor, integrity and courage to assault your own fellow serviceperson. Disgusting.