AP/ February 22, 2013, 8:47 PM

Original Iwo Jima monument unsold at NYC auction

The original 12 1/2-foot (4 meter) cast stone version of Felix de Weldon's iconic statue depicting soldiers raising the U.S. flag at Iwo Jima is on display, Friday, Feb. 22, 2013.

The original 12 1/2-foot (4 meter) cast stone version of Felix de Weldon's iconic statue depicting soldiers raising the U.S. flag at Iwo Jima is on display, Friday, Feb. 22, 2013. / AP Photo/Mary Altaffer

NEW YORK A long-forgotten World War II statue of the famous flag-raising at Iwo Jima that had been expected to sell for as much as $1.8 million was passed on by bidders in an auction on Friday.

Bidding for the 12 1/2-foot-tall sculpture of the 1945 flag-raising reached as high as $950,000, below the undisclosed minimum sales price, Bonhams auction house said.

"We're a little disappointed with what happened with the sculpture," Bonhams Maritime Art Department sales specialist Gregg K. Dietrich said.

Three potential buyers placed competing bids for four or five minutes, Dietrich said.

The sculpture's owner, military historian and collector Rodney Hilton Brown, did not wish to discuss the results of the auction.

Dietrich said prospective buyers could purchase the sculpture through Bonhams, which will negotiate a price on the seller's behalf.

Play Video

Original Iwo Jima sculpture up for auction

History buffs have fawned over the sculpture, a miniature of the familiar 32-foot-tall bronze Marine Corps War Memorial in Arlington, Va. That sculpture, designed by Felix de Weldon, was patterned after a Pulitzer Prize-winning Associated Press image of the Feb. 23, 1945, flag-raising by Marines and a Navy Corpsman on Iwo Jima's Mount Suribachi.

The smaller sculpture was largely forgotten about for more than four decades after de Walden placed it in the back of his studio, covering it with a tarp. That's where Brown found it in 1990 while researching a book on de Weldon. It was in desperate need of restoration.

Brown bought the 5-ton monument, paying for it with cash and two peculiar collectors' items: a Stradivarius violin and a silver Newport yachting trophy from the 1920s.

In 1995, Brown presented a restored version of the statute to the Intrepid Sea, Air and Space Museum on the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Iwo Jima.

Brown said earlier this month he wanted to sell the sculpture because "it doesn't fit in my living room."

"I want to find it a good home," he said, "so we can pass the flag onto somebody else."

© 2013 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
26 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
LindaStevenson says:
Oh for Pete's sake - yes, this statue belongs at the Marine Corps Museum in Quantico... but if I hear one more person say "the owner should DONATE it, I think I'll throw up. The guy spent all kinds of money restoring it, AFTER buying it himself. Now you want him to give it away? How 'bout THIS for a plan - The auction house said they would negotiate with the owner - the statue was expected to fetch "up to" $1.8 million. How many Marines and former Marines are there out there? Oh no, wait - there ARE no FORMER Marines. So between all of you - if EVERYone pools their funds, it might cost .50 to a buck each. If NOT everyone has a buck they want 'donate', it might be a bit more. Is that do-able? You just need to nominate someone to collect the money. Problem solved.
reply
skeezix06 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
If he/she could afford to buy something like that in the first place, it's reasonable to assume he/she could donate it without taking a financial hit that he/she can't afford. I suppose he/she could try to strike a bargain where they named a building or a ship or a tank after him/her. But I think it is very reasonable to expect it to be donated. Call it the action of a person who loves their country.
skeezix06 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
maybe a Medal of Freedom in exchange for the donation.
See all 5 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
relecuyer says:
It would be generous and thoughtful if the owner did donate the model to the U.S. Marine Corps for placement at a Corps base. In the 1970s, I lived in an apartment across Arlington Blvd. from the statue. From time to time, I saw the U.S. Marine Band and the Color Guard practicing on the grounds and tourists taking pictures of the statue.

The sad fact today is that many young people know nothing of World War II and the sacrifices made at Iwo Jima, Guadalcanal, Luzon, Midway, the Aleutians, elsewhere in the European and Pacific Theaters. Nor did the world learn a lesson as war and the devastation war causes continue in our present time.

While the statue captures the photographed moment in time at Iwo, it also honors the sacrifices of millions of men and women in the front lines of military engagements in all places and in all times. The model is a reflection of that national tribute of gratitude from our country to all who have ever served. Rosalie L'Ecuyer, Fairbanks, Alaska
reply
skeezix06 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
People are not likely to want to tour or, in the current atmosphere, allowed to tour a marine corp base. The only people who will see it there will be members of the military.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
skeezix06 says:
The Smithsonian would be an excellent permanent home for it but I think it should be a donation, not a purchase.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Semper_Fi_Yall says:
Contact "The National Museum of the Marine Corps" in Triangle,VA and donate to place that will keep it were it belongs and protect it. You could probably right it off too.

Semper Fi
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
judymar14 says:
Disgusting a monument such as this should be 'owned' period. It belongs to the American people and should be cared for by American taxpayers for the up-keep. A few less toilets bought by our government for hundreds $ would keep it as it should be, in repair.
reply
MickProPer replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It's not a "monument"; it's an artist's mock-up - a normal step in making a large sculpture. The Maryhill Museum in Washington State has a whole collection of miniature Rodan sculptures and mockups if thinks like hands and feet. Many artists break up and discard these, when the final piece is done.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
hypnotoad72 says:
So we place more value on high school students hitting a ball on a stick than we do anything academic or historical.

Nobody should be surprised by how our society has reshaped what is defined as 'valuable'.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
pitai says:
I understand it's only plaster so it needs to be kept inside.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
js555554 says:
The caption under the picture is wrong.

"...iconic statue depicting soldiers raising the U.S. flag at Iwo Jima..."

They were not soldiers. They were Marines! There is a difference.
reply
myopinion57 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You're right! Marines' arms are a lot longer!! :-D Posted with professional respect and admiration for all U.S. Marines. Semper Fi! -- from an old soldier.
hypnotoad72 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
http://www.google.com/search?q=marine+indicted

The few, the proud, the marketed catchphrase by raving egoists.

"Soldier" is a sufficient and still very noble term...
See all 4 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ammo17 says:
this statue should be on the front lawn of the whitehouse.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nohater says:
owner should donate it to a museum. it is a model of what ultimately ended up as the monument. the owner could also donate it to the USMC who could then place it at MCRD or PI training depots.
reply
hypnotoad72 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I agree.

But that's not us for decide, in a free market...
See all 26 Comments