CBS/AP/ December 31, 2012, 10:34 AM

Investigation ongoing in deadly Ore. bus crash

Emergency personnel respond to the scene of a multiple-fatality accident where a tour bus careened through a guardrail along an icy Oregon highway and slid down a steep embankment, Sunday, Dec. 30, 2012, about 15 miles east of Pendleton, Ore. Nine people were killed.

Emergency personnel respond to the scene of a multiple-fatality accident where a tour bus careened through a guardrail along an icy Oregon highway and slid down a steep embankment, Sunday, Dec. 30, 2012, about 15 miles east of Pendleton, Ore. Nine people were killed. / AP Photo/East Oregonian, Tim Trainor

PENDLETON, Ore. Bad weather in the northwest may be to blame for a tour bus accident Sunday that killed nine passengers and injured at least 26 others, but police say the investigation is ongoing.

The bus' driver lost control about 10:30 a.m. along a rural part of Oregon's Interstate 84 near Pendleton. A steel guardrail did little to keep the tour bus -- and its roughly 40 passengers -- from going over an embankment and dropping 85 feet, reports correspondent Lee Cowan.

This stretch of I-84 (a major east-west highway that follows the Columbia River Gorge) is so notorious that state transportation officials have published a specific advisory warning of its dangers.

Lt. Gregg Hastings of Oregon State Patrol said the bus crashed along the west end of the Blue Mountains, and west of an area called Deadman Pass. The area is well known locally for its hazards, and the state transportation department advises truck drivers that "some of the most changeable and severe weather conditions in the Northwest" can lead to slick conditions and poor visibility. Drivers are urged to use "extreme caution and defensive driving techniques," and warned that snow and black ice are common in the fall through the spring.

"We're not blaming road conditions," said Lt. Hastings. "We know that there was some snow and ice on area roads, but the investigation is just beginning."

The driver of the bus was injured, but survived. That testimony -- more than anyone's -- will be able to tell investigators just what went wrong.

The bus crashed near the start of a 7-mile section of road that winds down a hill. The weather Sunday was hardly optimal - and made getting down to the injured and dying a time-consuming process, officials said. Dozens of rescuers followed a black scar down the side of the ravine to find the bus at the bottom -- resting upright, but with significant damage.

"There was snow on the ground which made pretty treacherous, so we used a haul system to get the patients or some of the patients from the crash site . . . back up to the highway so they could be transported to medical facilities," said Jim Voelz of the La Grande Rural Fire Department.

The most seriously hurt were air-lifted to hospitals as far away as Portland and Boise, Idaho.

The East Oregonian said it spoke with two South Korean passengers, ages 16 and 17. Both said through a translator that they were seated near the rear of the bus when it swerved a few times, hit the guardrail and flipped. They described breaking glass and seeing passengers pinned by their seats as the bus slid down the hill. Both said that they feared for their lives.

The paper said that the teens, one of whom injured a knee and the other suffered a broken collarbone, were staying at a hotel arranged by the Red Cross.

The bus had been carrying about 40 people. St. Anthony Hospital in Pendleton treated 26 of them, said hospital spokesman Larry Blanc. Five of those treated at St. Anthony were transported to other facilities.

Blanc did not elaborate on the nature of the injuries but told the Oregonian that the hospital brought in additional staff to handle the rush of patients and did a lot of X-ray imaging.

The bus owned by Mi Joo Travel was headed, state police say, from Las Vegas to Vancouver, Canada.

A woman who answered the phone at a listing for the Vancouver-based company confirmed with The Associated Press that it owned the bus and said it was on a tour of the Western U.S. She declined to give her name.

A bus safety website run by the U.S. Department of Transportation said Mi Joo Tour & Travel has six buses, none of which have been involved in any accidents in at least the past two years.

The bus crash was the second fatal accident in Oregon on Sunday morning. A 69-year-old man died in a rollover accident on I-84, about 30 miles west of where the bus accident took place.

Sunday's Oregon bus crash comes more than two months after another chartered tour bus veered off a highway in October in northern Arizona, killing the driver and injuring dozens of passengers who were mostly tourists from Asia and Europe. Authorities say the driver likely had a medical episode.

A spokesman for the American Bus Association said buses carry more than 700 million passengers a year in the United States.

"The industry as a whole is a very safe industry," said Dan Ronan of the Washington, D.C.,-based group. "There are only a handful of accidents every year. Comparatively speaking, we're the safest form of surface transportation."

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
19 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
canineworld says:
I just don't understand the statistics on this accident. If there were 40 passengers and one bus driver, how did 9 die and 39 get injured? That would add up to 48 people being on the bus. Did they have 7 extra bus drivers?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cubscout09 says:
FredSweatfield says:
... That stretch of road has and always will be one of the deadliest and dangerous on I-84.

CubScout says:

Keep in mind, the grade drops 2,500 feet in that seven miles. This is a challenge to the best of drivers in the best of weather. And the hillsides are better than 100% slope. I know, I've climbed them, but, that is another story.

Xmas eve, 1988, like an idiot, I took off into a blizzard Eastbound on I-84. I stopped at LaGrande to replace my destroyed chains and a westbound traveler told me that the pass was like a war zone, 47 odd wrecked semi trucks strewn all over the median and shoulders. Four harrowing hours later, I made it through to Pendleton at the bottom of the hill and checked into a motel for the rest of night.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jetmag26 says:
The previous comments aren't serious, right? The answer isn't banning buses, right? You all don't actually believe that we should ban anything that could cause harm, right? You aren't actually saying we should follow China's lead and not complain, right?

Tell me you all were joking. Please.
reply
john92021 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
we need to ban cold and ice and dark and death and stupidity.
tibiaornottibia replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nobody - almost as serious as the idiots that believe that high capacity magazines are good thing for hunting and protecting oneself.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
FredSweatfield says:
You people crack me up. First off.... Try and get a drivers licence to operate a bus. I think you will find it is a very stringent test. So as to your comment of don't know where they get those drivers is a bit stiff. Next is the road conditions. That stretch of road has and always will be one of the deadliest and dangerous on I-84. Everyone knows that, and I am sure the driver of that bus knew it as well. As far as mass transit goes. It is and will always be within the infrastructure to have buses and trains and planes and vehicles that carry more then one or two people at a time. Better Guard rail system would be a start. Maybe the Highway Division should spend a bit more money on sand and salt as well for that stretch of roadway. But to put down multi-person transportation... GET REAL...
reply
jetmag26 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Thank you Fred! I live in Portland and I don't venture out East during the winter but I know that here in town, we don't use salt or de-icer on roads because it's bad for the salmon. Oregon has to work on priorities.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
promytius says:
"Guard rail"? unfortunately it was just an "accident very possible here" marker.
Smaller vehicles, actual Guard Rails that CAN ACTUALLY stop a vehicle, lower speeds, smarter driving; all solutions, all too late.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
j324 says:
Only one solution to this....Ban high capacity vehicles. The risk of mass deaths is too great when you have more than 10 passengers in a vehicle.
reply
Colt4542 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
So ban bus's, airplanes, trains? How about banning any gathering of more than 10 people? Only suggestion I can think of is seat belts. If they are not already bus's they should be.
tibiaornottibia replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Nuclear warheads are the answer. Warheads don't kill people....
linkicon reporticon emailicon
canislupus16 says:
"The industry as a whole is a very safe industry," said Dan Ronan of the Washington, D.C.,-based group. "There are only a handful of accidents every year. Comparatively speaking, we're the safest form of surface transportation."
Wrong. Annual deaths per train passenger-mile are half that per bus passenger-mile.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Sax1031 says:
when are we going to ban high capacity vehicles?
reply
Bernie22405 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I agree. No one really needs to have these kinds of high speed, high capacity vehicles except the police (prisoner transport) and the military (troop transport). This country was settled on foot and horseback and that should be good enough for anyone. And let's also ban those "sports" cars from everywhere except designated, police monitored tracks.
You_No replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
They should restrict driving to only those who would use automobiles for sport, and only after a high-speed road course F1 training session, licensed and coordinated by the feds.

Nobody needs a 5 passenger car when a 2 seat Mini-Cooper would do. I mean, how many people do you actually see car-pooling? And if they need to take more than a few people most municipalities have some sort of transit company they can call. We do have buses people...

It's like, hello! They use buses and trolley's and trains in China, and you certainly don't hear the Chinese complaining about anything.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
fendferyerself says:
you will never see me on one of those tour buses or "casino" buses - never! and especially not during the winter months.
you have no idea where they get these drivers from or how long they have been driving a huge vehicle like a bus, never mind on top of very bad winter conditions.
what a way "to go". ON a tour bus! My condolences to the families of the deceased.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
maiingan says:
Slick conditions. Snowy road. Black Ice. Steep drop-off.
Build a better guard rail?
Tire chains are already available for wintertime road-traction problems.
reply
See all 19 Comments