CBS/AP/ December 28, 2012, 1:13 AM

Another NYC "subway push" death

Scene outside NYC subway station where man was pushed to his death onto tracks in front of oncoming train on night of Dec. 27, 2012, according to police, in the city's second such incident this month.

Scene outside NYC subway station where man was pushed to his death onto tracks in front of oncoming train on night of Dec. 27, 2012, according to police, in the city's second such incident this month. / WCBS-TV/CBS

NEW YORK A mumbling woman pushed a man to his death in front of a subway train on Thursday night, the second time this month someone has been killed in such nightmarish fashion, police said.

The man was standing on the elevated platform of a 7 train in Queens at about 8 p.m. when he was shoved by the woman, who witnesses said had been following him closely and mumbling to herself, New York Police Department chief spokesman Paul Browne said.

When the train pulled in, the woman got up from a nearby bench and shoved the man down, he said. The man had been standing with his back to her.

Authorities say the woman waited until the last possible second before pushing the man, reports CBS New York station WCBS-TV.

It didn't appear the man noticed her before he was shoved onto the tracks, police said. The condition of the man's body was making it difficult to identify him, police said.

"Oh my God. That ... I've never heard of that. That is really ... a woman pushed a man. ... Oh my God. That is really crazy," area resident Shiek Hossain told WCBS-TV.

The woman fled, and police were searching for her. She was described as Hispanic, in her 20s, heavyset and about 5-foot-5, wearing a blue, white and gray ski jacket and Nike sneakers with gray on top and red on the bottom.

It was unclear if the man and the woman knew each other or if anyone tried to help the man up before he was struck by the train and killed.

There was no video of the incident at the station on Queens Boulevard in the Sunnyside neighborhood. Detectives canvassed the neighborhood for useable video.

On Dec. 3, 58-year-old Ki-Suck Han was shoved in front of a train in Times Square. A photograph of him on the tracks a split second before he was killed was published on the front of the New York Post the next day, causing an uproar and debate over whether the photographer, who had been waiting for a train, should have tried to help him and whether the newspaper should have run the image. Apparently no one else tried to help up Han, either.

A homeless man, 30-year-old Naeem Davis, was charged with murder in Han's death and was ordered held without bail. He has pleaded not guilty and has said that Han was the aggressor and had attacked him first. The two men hadn't met before.

Service was suspended Thursday night on the 7 train line, which connects Manhattan and Queens, and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority was using buses to shuttle riders while police investigated.

Being pushed onto the train tracks is a silent fear for many of the commuters who ride the city's subway a total of more than 5.2 million times on an average weekday, but deaths are rare.

Among the more high-profile cases was the January 1999 death of aspiring screenwriter Kendra Webdale, who was shoved by a former mental patient. After that, the state Legislature passed Kendra's Law, which lets mental health authorities supervise patients who live outside institutions to make sure they are taking their medications and aren't threats to safety.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
39 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
NYCITY1BOY1 says:
THIS IS RIDICULOUS with all the money mta get from all customers they should get a HD 1080 HIGH DEFINITION CAMERAS IN ALL THE STATIONS COME ON PEOPLE WE ARE IN 2012 NOT IN THE 30'S and more police agents in every station
i say it again ridiculoussssssssssss
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
USSAmerikan says:
Hummm... Two ways to view this. Outlaw trains, since they are inherently evil or is it that trains don't kill people, people kill people? I think Obama needs to appoint a czar to investigate. Or maybe he could get a clue and assemble a team of qualified professionals to identify a course of action to deal with the mental health epidemic we are living with, coupled with the levels of explicit, gratuitous violence our society is exposed to thanks to Hollywood.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
The13thStep says:
I think we need to ban all motorized vehicles, planes etc... They kill people... :/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
j324 says:
How many innocent people need to die from these trains before we do something about them? Look at all of the millions of people that were transported to their deaths by these "assault trains" in Germany alone. Not to mention, Russia, China, and Cambodia. When will we refuse to accept something so big, going so fast, around so many people. I demand action! Ban the trains!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
BigMykul says:
Time to ban subways.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
taxed01 says:
Oh gee - she is nuts, so it was OK - just a cry for help. Now we have to make sure all her "needs" are met. In our so-called justice system the victim doesn't count. Neither does justice.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
democracy8 says:
Not trying to blame the victim here, but anytime I had to take a train or subway, I made sure to stand at the rear of the platform with my back against a wall or column until the train was completely in the station.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Zardoz333 says:
***! We're the witness in shock? Not a single one even tried to stop the murderous skank. To think a close friend of mine moved to this ******** of a city. New Yorkers care my @$$!
reply
mainedemocrat replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
in this case it doesn't sound like anyone had time to react
nomoregrnbeans replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Have you ever been to NYC? This tragedy aside, it is one of the safest, greatest cities in the world. Don't hate on NY; We don't want people like you there anyway.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
zerses says:
Someone who pushes anyone onto the tracks of an oncoming train IS mentally ill.

Again, I will echo those of you who have spoken the truth, this is about mental illness, no gun was here, no knife, just a person who has no common sense, probably close to illiterate and probably has more problems than the "average" joe.

Our nation is becoming sick and thug-fested - and you want to think this is about "guns"?

Look at Chicago with close to FIVE HUNDRED - for those of you who are functionally illiterate that is CLOSE to 500.

Look at Detroit.

Look at Los Angeles.

Look at SO many cities where mental health violence has lead to deaths.

The conversation must turn to the way we teach and the way we DO NOT TEACH any longer - our schools are no longer safe because we made them so - No Child Left Behind also meant the mentally ILL people!
reply
gbgentleman replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
No child left behind is the worst piece of crap to ever exist in our education system. It is no longer a child's fault or a parent's fault if the child refuses to learn, it is the teacher's fault.

What happens when a teacher's salary is linked to test? The teacher is going to do exactly what the rest of us do, teach the test instead of the subject.

What we have become is a country of excuse makers. It's never our fault, it's their fault.

And NO Mentally ill children do NOT belong in schools. The teachers have enough trouble dealing with children who cause enough trouble without adding mental illness to the equation.
WiseAsOwl replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I believe GBGENTLEMAN knows what he's talking about..
See all 4 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mmminnick says:
No gun here just your average American pshyco. When are we going to start a study to find out what we do as a society to create these head cases who unfortunately kill people!
reply
See all 39 Comments