South Dakota executes first inmate since 2007

Death-penalty opponent Reynold Nesiba speaks to crowd of protesters outside the South Dakota Penitentiary in Sioux Falls, S.D., Monday, in anticipation of execution of Eric Robert / AP Photo/Amber Hunt

SIOUX FALLS, S.D. A South Dakota man who beat a prison guard with a pipe and covered his head in plastic wrap to kill him during a failed escape attempt was put to death Monday, in the state's first execution since 2007.

Eric Robert, 50, received a lethal injection and was pronounced dead at the state penitentiary in Sioux Falls at 10:24 p.m. He is the first South Dakota inmate to die under the state's new single-drug lethal injection method, and only the 17th person to be executed in the state or Dakota Territory since 1877.

Robert had no expression on his face. Asked if he had a last statement, Robert said: "In the name of justice and liberty and mercy, I authorize and forgive Warden Douglas Weber to execute me for the crimes. It is done."

As the drug was administered, the clean-shaven Robert, wearing orange inmate pants with a white blanket wrapped around his upper body, appeared to be clearing his throat and then began gasping heavily. He then snored for about 30 seconds. His eyes remained opened throughout and his skin turned pale, eventually gaining a purplish hue.

Robert was put to death in the same prison where he killed guard Ronald "RJ" Johnson during an escape attempt on April 12, 2011. Robert was serving an 80-year sentence on a kidnapping conviction when he tried to break out with fellow inmate Rodney Berget, 50.

Johnson's widow, Lynette, said after the execution that she knows Robert's death will not bring back her husband, her children's father or her grandchildren's grandfather.

"But we do know that the employees of the Department of Corrections and the public in general will be just a little bit safer now," Lynette Johnson said. "We need to have more attention and focus on the safety of all of the correctional officers in the state of South Dakota. Ron, none of you will ever know how great he is and is missed. We stand proud for Ron."

Lynette Johnson, her two children and their spouses all witnessed the execution. No one from Robert's family was in attendance.

People on both sides of the death penalty debate gathered outside the penitentiary as Robert was put to death.

Elaine Engelgau, 56, who opposes the death penalty, said it doesn't make sense that the state would do the very thing that they are punishing the person for.

At least one person driving by yelled a profanity about Robert to her.

Tonya Reyelts-Doese said Robert's death will help bring some closure to the Johnson family. She was among a handful of people waving banners and flags in support of Johnson and his family.

Robert ate his last meal of ice cream with his lawyer, Mark Kadi, on Saturday night before fasting for 40 hours for religious reasons.

After the execution, Kadi said the execution was very "orderly and polished."

"The problem was it was too orderly. It was so antiseptic and peaceful that it masked what was being done to the person," Kadi said. "If more people were able to see the events, there would be fewer of them."

Johnson was working alone the morning of his death — also his 63rd birthday — in a part of the prison known as Pheasantland Industries, where inmates work on upholstery, signs, custom furniture and other projects. Authorities said the inmates beat Johnson with a pipe, covered his head in plastic wrap and left his body on the floor.

Robert then put on Johnson's pants, hat and jacket and approached the prison's west gate. With his head down, he pushed a cart loaded with two boxes. Berget was hidden in one of the boxes, according to a report filed by a prison worker after the slaying.

Other guards became suspicious as the men got closer to the gate. When confronted, Robert beat one guard; other guards quickly arrived and detained both inmates.

Months later, Robert told a judge his only regret was that he hadn't killed more guards. He pleaded guilty to Johnson's slaying and asked to be sentenced to death, telling a judge last October that he would otherwise kill again. He never appealed his sentence and even tried to bypass a mandatory state review in hopes of expediting his death.

Berget also has pleaded guilty in the killing but has appealed his death sentence. A third inmate, Michael Nordman, 47, was given a life sentence for providing materials used in the slaying.

Robert's execution could be the first of two in as many weeks. Donald Moeller is scheduled to be put to death the week of Oct. 28 for the 1990 kidnapping, rape and murder of a 9-year-old girl. Robert had been on death row only for about a year, Moeller has been there for more than two decades. Only three other inmates currently are on the state's death row.

South Dakota's last execution before Monday took place in 2007, and that was the first in the state for 60 years.

"You have few people on death row, few executions, and then you have this coincidence of cases coming all at once," said Richard Dieter, executive director of the nonprofit Death Penalty Information Center. "When people waive appeals, their cases start to move more quickly."

[Bojax39]

"South Dakota man who beat a prison guard with a pipe and covered his head in plastic wrap to kill him during a failed escape attempt was put to death Monday"

And all the while there were bleeding hearts toting signs and weeping for this animal while he got what was coming to him.

You get people doing horrendous things then being convicted and sitting on death row on the taxpayer's dime for decades during appeal after appeal while misguided idiots beg for their lives and an end to barbarity.

Pathetic.

[lukasiwicz]

Good riddance to bad rubbish. Enough said.

[1tenthAngel]

Liberal women are stupid. They can't get the concept of birth control, but they do get the concept of aborton. I agree with the death sentence, some people are too evil for us to feed and clothe for the next 40 years.
Oxymoron.

[Bojax39]

1tenthAngel says: "Liberal women are stupid. They can't get the concept of birth control, but they do get the concept of abortion."

Worse yet, many of these morons think abortion IS a form of birth control. There are cases where abortion is necessary, unfortunately. But using it as a sort of after the fact birth control while citing the old "my body, my choice" saw is far more barbarous than executing some twisted animal.

[CraigDV]

After reading about these killers, rapists etc. being held for years and years on our tax dollars, I have a greater appreciation for the justice system in China. After a trial,if the person is sentenced to death, they take them immediately from the cortroom and carry out the sentence. And then the family must pay for the expense of the execution before they can claim the body.

[MidRoadAlone]

"The problem was it was too orderly. It was so antiseptic and peaceful that it masked what was being done to the person," Kadi said. "If more people were able to see the events, there would be fewer of them."

Maybe they should have beat him in the head with a pipe and then wrapped his head in plastic - like he did his victim.

It is always amazing to watch the liberals in front of the prison saying that a brutal murderers life is sacred - and then they march over to a womens' "Reproductive Rights" rally to assure the right to kill an unborn child - without due process.

[lifeduringwartime]

This is how the death penalty should work about a year and a half after the crime and he paid the price. And those people in the picture represent the Catholic Church ( I live near Souix Falls) which is total b.s. but what do you expect from pedo protectors.

[djseavy]

If we could get the kinks worked out in the system, and eliminate the possibility that an innocent person could be executed thanks to crooked prosecutors, police, etc., I'd support the death penalty. In this case, where there is no doubt whatsoever, I'd say the system worked as it should. It's amazing how Beget was involed in a killing, but is too weak to accept his punishment. At least Robert took what he had coming and didn't try to weasle his way out of it. His last statement was rather contradictory, since he asked for the death penalty (probably would have received it anyway) but waived his appeals, then "forgave" the warden.

[andypost]

Execute all three of them. if there was any doubt as to whether these men could and would be reformed is now just a moot point.
No need to waste any more tax payer money. That money could be used elsewhere in helping people who deserve it.