CBS/AP/ September 18, 2012, 1:53 PM

Man who left injured dog on mountain speaks out

(CBS/AP) A hiker who abandoned his injured five-year-old German shepard/Rottweiler on a Colorado mountain last month spoke out after receiving death threats for his action, CBS affiliate KCNC Denver reported Sunday.

Anthony Ortolani of Westminster said that he accepts responsibility for taking his 112-pound dog Missy on the trip that turned out arduous for her. The hiker said that the dog's paws began to bleed in the saddle area between Mount Bierstadt and Mount Evans, said KCNC. Ortolani said he tried to carry the injured animal for two hours; his feet were hurt too.

Faced with approaching bad weather and lack of water, Ortolani abandoned Missy.

"Carrying her down, unfortunately caused her more injury. She fought with me and squirmed off my shoulders, and I dropped her on some rocks and she got hurt worse," Ortolani said.

Hikers found the dog days later and organized a volunteer recovery effort, bringing Missy down from Mount Bierstadt after an eight-day ordeal.

"Everybody says 'Why didn't you go back?' My physical condition was significantly deteriorated, my emotional condition was no good. I thought she was dead," said Ortolani.

After Ortolani learned of the rescue, he asked for his dog back. But Clear Creek County authorities conducted an investigation and charged him with animal cruelty.

His lawyer, Jennifer Edwards, said her client hopes to make a plea deal.

Ortolani said that he paid approximately $5,000 in veterineary and boarding expenses. He says now that he would prefer one of the rescuers adopting Missy rather than her ending up in a shelter where she is held at the moment.

The decision to give up custody of Missy was part of a possible plea bargain.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
99 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Jaylah54200 says:
I only know that if that had happened to me, and I was physically unable to rescue my dog myself, the very FIRST damn thing I would have done when I got to "civilization" would be to start making phone calls to find somebody to help me go back and get my dog. Dead or alive.

I sure as sh*t wouldn't have waited for somebody else to find my injured dog alive, and then claim it wasn't my fault and I wanted my dog back.

My dog got old and I had to have him euthanized on March 1, 2011. I cried for three straight days. There is just no WAY I could have left him on a mountain, not knowing for sure if he was alive or not. And even if I had known for sure that he was dead, there was no way I could have just left his body there.

My dog thought the sun and the moon rose and set on me for 12 years. I had a stroke about 8 years ago, and I credit my dog with the fact that I learned to talk and write again. I had to spend a long time in the hospital (several hundred miles away from where I live) learning how again, and I worked my fanny off in therapy classes because I wanted to get home to my dog again so bad.

There is just no WAY I could have left my dog to die.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
all_legs says:
Ok lets analyze this. Why in the world would you take a dog over terrain you knew was not an easy climb and in fact rocky. That dog should have been at home, or did you just plan to leave her? You DO NOT deserve any animal. To top it off you walked off and left her and she was badly injured that's when the dog no longer belongs with you. You forfeited any and all rights when you went off and left her. WHY didn't you go back for her? Don't give me any hog wash about your feet were hurt too. Missy was YOUR RESPONSIBILITY. Even if you were hurt you still should have manned up and gone back to get your dog.
reply
alexandra166 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I have 3 german shepherds that I walk everyday on rocky terrain for over an hour. Each summer in Austin, I see some well meaning person who decides to take their dog out on the trail, who never gets walked on this terrain, with torn up blood paw pads. This guy obviously didn't exercise this dog on this type of trail at all, or its paws would not have been bleeding. I also heard that he did not report that he had left his dog for dead up on the mountain. I agree that he does not deserve ANY animal, and feel he should spend some time in JAIL, so maybe he can learn a lesson. A dog is a companion, a living creature, and if the tables had been turned that dog would have stayed by his side. I am sick of hearing about people who treat animals like crap and then are surprised when things don't go their way. Of course you won't get your dog back you idiot. I hope NO ONE ever gives you a pet again.
Poor animal. Hope it gets a better home.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
doubledumassonU says:
"Everybody says 'Why didn't you go back?' My physical condition was significantly deteriorated, my emotional condition was no good. I thought she was dead," said Ortolani.

What a jackass!! Any normal human would have gone back (which begs the argument that any normal human wouldn't have left her there, et cetera). I am constantly stunned by the cruel behavior tossed off to animals by their owners, let alone total strangers. I would have fined this guy more. I would have sent in a death threat myself. He should have stayed with her. People found the dog two days later; they would have found his sorry and selfish ass too.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Daniel_MD says:
Why didn't he just tie the dog to the roof of his car?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
StarNoquisi says:
Poor Missy. That selfish idiot should rot in jail. Maybe the Judge should put his butt in an animal shelter. Dogs give us unconditional love and they would never abandon us under any circumstance. I hope Missy gets a wonderful, loving home that she so rightly deserves.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
andie52 says:
if that idiot had been badly injured his dog would never have left his side
reply
alexandra166 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
exactly. My GSD stays by my side at all times. We have been inseparable since the day I brought her home. What kind of monster leaves his best friend alone to die on a mountain. He could have at least made calls to get other people to go back up and get her. What a ******
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mari1963 says:
This idiot should have never taken this dog out there with him in the first place. He should be in jail! He is a huge loser and shame on a judge for not throwing him in jail. Or how about we take him up on a mountain and leave him there alone to fend for himself with two broken feet.

I hope Missy gets a great home. She deserves one! I wish I could take her. She is a sweet dog.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Bush-cheney-R-Terrorists says:
He abandoned the dog, but the dog would not have abandoned him. In fact she followed him probably knowing it was not survivable.
reply
doubledumassonU replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You're so right!!!
alexandra166 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
exactly. THere is nothing he or any of us can say that changes the fact that this guy was stupid, selfish and cruel. He should be doing jail time.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
KansasCity-2012 says:
This story is a great moral dilemma to read about. I saw a movie about a similar subject where a man abandoned his dogs on the South Pole and returned to save them, but again, it was a movie and can't be considered a valid yardstick to size up the behavior of a citizen who entered into a distressful situation and had to rescue himself.

It doesn't appear to be a good use of tax money to prosecute this citizen and supervise his behavior. We are not in a prosperous economy and the victim in the event included the citizen (defendant) himself. Justice won't be served and better use of tax dollars exist.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
islandr1 says:
Dirtbag puts his dog in jeopardy carried it for a couple of hours whines about his sore feet then abandons the dog to die was found and cared for then asks for the dog back. WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU? You should never be allowed to own another pet again As@$ole
reply
doubledumassonU replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
So passionate; so correct!
See all 99 Comments