CBS stands by decision to hide ID of Navy SEAL
A retired Navy SEAL who was present at the killing of Osama bin Laden has written a book about the raid. The former SEAL, who uses the pseudonym Mark Owen, speaks about the mission publicly for the first time with Scott Pelley for "60 Minutes."
(CBS/AP) NEW YORK - CBS News is disguising the identity of a retired Navy SEAL who wrote a book about the raid that killed Osama bin Laden so it can protect "an American hero" -- even though other media outlets have said who he is.
CBS News Chairman Jeff Fager told the Associated Press on Thursday he'd make the same decision to withhold the identity even if the network hadn't landed an exclusive interview with the author, who participated in the May 2011 raid in Pakistan. Scott Pelley's interview with the ex-SEAL will air on "60 Minutes" on Sept. 9 and was previewed on the "CBS Evening News" on Wednesday.
The book, titled "No Easy Day" and written by one of the men in the room when the al Qaeda leader was killed in the May 2011 raid, was written under the pseudonym of Mark Owen. Last week, Fox News Channel first reported Owens' real identity and The AP also identified him after getting independent confirmation. CBS News does not identify members of classified counter-terrorism units.
Even after the other organizations revealed Owen's identity, Fager said he made sure that all parts of his news organization did not.
"This is an American hero," Fager said. "He risked his life to do this job. Isn't it our responsibility to protect him? To hear his story is one thing, but to reveal his name so he becomes a target? I'd like to think that news people are Americans first. I feel that way."
For the interview, CBS News disguised Owen's voice. A makeup person also concealed the author's looks so effectively before the "60 Minutes" interview that Pelley, who had met him three times before, did not recognize the author upon entering the room, said Fager, who is also executive producer of "60 Minutes."
After identifying the SEAL, Fox News Executive Vice President and Executive Editor John Moody said that "once you write a book, anonymously or not, you have no reasonable expectation of privacy."
The AP said it decided to use his name because it was already on the Internet and on the air, so the expectation of keeping his name out of the greater public was very low. The news organization said informed Special Operations Command that it was going to use the name, and no government agency tried to dissuade the news organization.
Fager said he's not sure what the value of reporting Owen's real name is for the viewer.
"We're not in the business of chasing down people who work in these agencies, whether it's a Navy SEAL or the CIA, and revealing their names to the public," he said.
Jose A. Rodriguez Jr., former director of the National Clandestine Service of the CIA, said it shouldn't be a surprise that the ex-SEAL's real name came out.
"It's almost to be expected in today's world when you write a book like he wrote that commands so much interest," said Rodriguez, who was responsible for helping to keep CIA employees' identities safe. Rodriguez ordered interrogation tapes of suspected al Qaeda members destroyed so the identities of the questioners could not be found out.
Rodriguez, author of "Hard Measures: How Aggressive CIA Actions After 9/11 Saved Lives," said he sympathized with the author's concern about his safety.
"If I were advising some of these media organizations, I would have urged them to be very cautious about leaking the true name of someone who participated in a raid to kill bin Laden," he said.
Bob Steele, a media ethics expert and professor at DePauw University, said the media have to set the bar high before granting anonymity to a book author. In this case, it's even more important for people to know the author, because the book makes an assertion that the raid did not go down quite like the Obama administration had reported.
"If you leave a name out of a story, you diminish its factual accuracy and its authenticity," Steele said. "A major piece of the jigsaw puzzle is missing."
ABC News has not used the author's real name because "the publisher's position that he could be endangered if named made sense," said Jeffrey Schneider, news division spokesman. ABC doesn't plan to reassess the decision unless the author decides to reveal his identity, he said. NBC News has not used the SEAL's name in any stories about the case.
CNN had not been using the author's real name because Pentagon officials had asked that it not be revealed, spokeswoman Bridget Leininger said. But on the air Thursday, CNN showed clips from CBS News' story and used his real name, saying it was being revealed "under the Pentagon's guidance."
"By this week, it was clear his real identity was not going to remain private, and we reported it," Leininger said.
Popular on CBSNews.com
- Port Authority releases photo of One WTC workers at dizzying heights
- Washington state bridge collapses 20 Photos
- Bridge collapse blamed on tractor-trailer 299 Comments
- Best U.S. beaches 2013 10 Photos
- Frantic 911 calls reveal chaos in Okla., following tornado
- Judge: Ariz. sheriff's office profiles Latinos 79 Comments
- No fatalities in I-5 bridge collapse in NW Wash.
- Clean-up efforts underway in Okla. 29 Photos