Religious group defends swastika banner

A banner flying over New Jersey beaches showed a swastika inside a Star of David / @sandeemusready/Twitter

(CBS News) LONG BEACH, N.J. - A religious group defended its display of a swastika over New Jersey beaches on Saturday, arguing it was trying to bring it back as a peaceful symbol rather than promote antisemitism.

The International Raelian Movement said a small plane dragging a banner with a swastika above Long Beach was a part of Swastika Rehabilitation Day, an attempt to "re-educate" the public about the symbol's pre-Nazi roots.

"Why should the swastika, a symbol of peace for more than 1.5 billion people in the world, offend the people of Manhattan?" said Thomas Kaenzig, Swastika Rehabilitation Day coordinator, said in a press release on the Raelian official website.

Beachgoers were shocked to see the image, which included the swastika symbol inside a Star of David and promoted the website proswastika.org. One Twitter user, Samantha Wagner, took a picture of the banner and asked, "Shd this symbol rly be revived? Roots aside, isn't the neg connotation to much?"

New York Times reporter Corey Kilgannon also snapped a picture of the banner after it flew over Manhattan. Don Pripstein, the president of the Jewish Community Center in Long Beach Island, New Jersey, told reporters he questioned the flyer's intentions.

In a response directed to Pripstein, the North American Raelian Movement director said they were trying to "negate - not forget the hate and fear carried out by Hitler and his followers."

"If the Jewish people would not hide in terror in the presence of this symbol but instead embrace it's true meaning, the world would stand in awe of this act of love," wrote Ricky Roehr.

Pripstein said regardless of what message the group was trying to get across, publicly displaying the swastika is still inappropriate.

"The image of the swastika is still so ingrained in the Jewish people," Pripstein said. "So many people have parents or grandparents who were affected by it. The image is so profound, a detestful thing ... it seems too soon."

The organization, which claims to have over 70,000 members worldwide, believes a group of scientists from another planet called the "Elohim" created life on Earth thousands of years ago. There is some debate about whether or not they should be classified as a cult.

Pope denounces cloning attempt by Raelian company

The Raelians said they also flew the banner along the U.S. West Coast, Australia and handed out flyers on the streets of Tel Aviv, Israel and Karlsruhe, Germany. (In Germany, it is illegal to show the swastika in public and the group said they are sending someone to court to challenge the law.)

Kaenzig, the coordinator of Swastika Rehabilitation Day, said the images didn't receive as much outrage in other parts of the world as it did on the East Coast.

"Obviously the Jewish community on the U.S. East Coast doesn't have the same knowledge as those in Israel. The fact that the Jewish community in America found our banner outrageous shows that there is still plenty of work to be done here," he wrote.

[Francis-Bellamy]

The Nazis symbol was not a swastika, and they did not call themselves Nazis. They called themselves socialists and they called their symbol a Hakenkreuz (hooked cross), as it was a type of cross, and they altered it for use to symbolize cr...ossed S-letters for socialism under the National Socialist German Workers Party (see the work of symbologist Dr. Rex Curry http://rexcurry.net/ ). It would make more sense if people spent less time about the swastika and more time complaining about the USA's Pledge of Allegiance (the origin of the Nazi salute and Nazi behavior. Again, see Dr. Curry's work). The pledge to the flag continues to be the origin of that kind of thought and behavior (with robotic chanting in unison on command every morning in government schools, and persecution for dissenters); only the gesture has changed.

[Rafterman11]

The organization, which claims to have over 70,000 members worldwide, believes a group of scientists from another planet called the "Elohim" created life on Earth thousands of years ago. There is some debate about whether or not they should be classified as a cult.

I can settle that debate for everyone right now.

"Yes"

You're welcome.

[Machipongo_John]

Clearly, the only purpose the "Elohim" have (I would rename them "Elohssa")is to cause outrage. The American Nazi party also wanted to bring "enlightenment" to Jewish areas around Chicago.

[ludvig1-2009]

Could the Elohim be from the planet Kolob?

[JustMeHereNow]

Sounded to me a lot like a couple of mice from Magrathea.

[hypnotoad72]

I recall two versions the base symbol can be drawn in - depending on which way the spokes pointed... one version, which Hitler used, represents his cult. The opposite direction is the peaceful version.

But that's a moot point. Many words and symbols change their meaning, usually when something big happens... Hitler's antics were not minor trifles...

It's too late to restore history, thanks to Hitler and his despicable little band of organized savages...


And given most people don't care for history, technical details, or much outside the lives of "reality show celebrities", any attempts of them to re-educate will be effectively futile.

The symbol is now associated with Hitler. He made the decision to co-opt something good into something evil. That confused many to begin with.

And the worst possibility is this group engendering an unintentional misunderstanding, since they might - accidentally - make people think they're supporters of Hitler and his vile cause.

[55minus5]

As in most cases, I agree with you. I have a set of books - Rudyard Kipling's works - the front page is framed with swastikas in every corner. But we're no longer in the 19th century. Cannot change that. What stuns me every time (and it shouldn't, already), is how inconsiderate some people are, and how persistent in their historical insensitivity they remain.