NPR dumps opera show over D.C. protest
This handout photo shows Lisa Simeone, a freelance radio host fired from a documentary program that airs on NPR affiliates after she became a spokeswoman for a Washington offshoot of the "Occupy Wall Street" protests. / AP
WASHINGTON - NPR will no longer distribute the affiliate-produced program "World of Opera" to about 60 stations across the country because the show host helped organize an ongoing Washington protest, a network official said Friday evening.
Instead, North Carolina-based classical music station WDAV, which produces the show, said it will distribute the nationally syndicated program on its own beginning Nov. 11. The station said it plans to keep Lisa Simeone as host and has said her involvement in a political protest does not affect her job as a music program host.
NPR spokeswoman Dana Davis Rehm said the network disagrees with the station on the role of program hosts but respects its position.
"Our view is it's a potential conflict of interest for any journalist or any individual who plays a public role on behalf of NPR to take an active part in a political movement or advocacy campaign," she told The Associated Press. "Doing so has the potential to compromise our reputation as an organization that strives to be impartial and unbiased."
Host fired from NPR show for role in "Occupy DC"
Rehm said any host with NPR attached to their title is a public figure representing the network as a whole. But she said "reasonable people can have different views about this." She said the negotiations with WDAV were civil and amicable.
NPR's ethics code states that "NPR journalists may not participate in marches and rallies" involving issues NPR covers. The code notes that some provisions may not apply to outside contributors. It uses a freelancer who primarily contributes arts coverage as an example.
Rehm said the network didn't need to cite the code in its decision to drop the show because its position on hosts' political activities was "even more fundamental."
Simeone, who lives in Baltimore, is a freelancer who has worked in radio and television for 25 years. She has hosted music shows and documentaries. She was fired Wednesday from a radio documentary program she hosted, "Soundprint," because she helped organize the demonstration, which has also protested against Wall Street and what participants call corporate greed.
"Soundprint" is heard on about 35 NPR affiliates and is produced by Maryland-based Soundprint Media Center Inc. The head of Soundprint said the company had adopted NPR's code of ethics as its own.
"World of Opera" is the only radio show in the nation devoted to broadcasting full-length operas from around the world, according to WDAV.
The Davidson, N.C.-based station will use the same distribution process as NPR and hopes to retain all the stations that have aired the program, spokeswoman Lisa Gray said. The network is assisting with the change in distribution, and it won't affect the listener's experience.
"We think it's really important to classical music that we continue to produce the show and make it available," Gray told the AP. "That's our primary concern, that we continue to be able to provide this programming to listeners and stations across the country."
WDAV had previously said it has a different mission than NPR and seeks to provide arts and cultural programming nationally and internationally, rather than news.
NPR had previously produced and distributed "World of Opera" in house until January 2010 when production was shifted to WDAV. The show has been in production for more than 20 years. It has featured performances from U.S. opera companies including Washington National Opera, Houston Grand Opera, Glimmerglass and New York City Opera, as well as operas from Paris, Vienna and elsewhere.
Popular on CBSNews.com
- Port Authority releases photo of One WTC workers at dizzying heights 140 Comments
- Massive train collision takes down highway overpass
- Washington state bridge collapses 20 Photos
- Thousands of U.S. bridges vulnerable to collapse
- Best U.S. beaches 2013 10 Photos
- Bridge collapse blamed on tractor-trailer 330 Comments
- Texas flooding turns deadly
- Deadly Angel Flight crash in upstate New York
Simeone's political advocacy does not affect her ability to host a show on the arts. This represents an unintelligent attempt to enforce policy where a nuance approach would be more appropriate.
NPR is however not all to blame for this unintelligent approach to policy though. The political climate created by republicans which creates an inflexible & politically partisan attitude on the national arts & information fora has no doubt resulted in this silly attempt to force 'one size' upon all participants.
Watch out moderate Republicans, they are coming for you next, and I am not kidding.
If I read the story correctly The show is still on the air and it is still on NPR. The people who listen to this show could probably care less who actually distributes the show. After all it will likely come on the same station at the same time.
Must be a really slow news day.
It also appears that NPR is citing an ethics policy that really doesn't appear to apply in this case as Simone is not a journalist. Given recent faux pas at NPR, it appears that they may be getting a little gun shy. Too bad as Simone's involvement in organizing protests doesn't seem to have anything to do with her opera show.