Edwards verdict: Government's case failed over Young's credibility
(CBS News) On Thursday, John Edwards, the former vice presidential nominee, was acquitted of one count of campaign finance fraud in connection with his run for the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination. The jury reported that it was hopelessly deadlocked on five other counts. So the judge declared a mistrial on those counts, ending the case.
How did the government fail its case? CBS Evening News anchor Scott Pelley spoke with Erin Moriarty of "48 Hours Mystery," who has been watching testimony in the courtroom.
Pelley: What appeared to be the central flaw in the government's case?
Moriarty: I think, simply put, it's Andrew Young, the government's key witness. The government built its case on his testimony. He's the one who said that John Edwards solicited the money from the two wealthy donors, then used it to hide his girlfriend from the American public as part of his campaign. But during cross-examination, Andrew Young had to admit that he used more than a million dollars of that money for his own house and I think his credibility was severely damaged [up] to that point.
Pelley: He used that money to build his own house -- he essentially stole it, is what he said.
Moriarty: He did and he was double dealing. He actually told one donor that he owed money and that he had already paid that with Bunny Mellon's money.
Pelley: So can prosecutors try again?
Moriarty: They can, and we saw that in the Roger Clemens case. But they are stuck with Andrew Young. I don't think it's likely they will.Edwards not guilty on 1 count; mistrial declared on other 5 counts
- Colo. senator who pushed for gun control may lose job
- 6/18: Officials say NSA stopped over 50 potential terror attacks; Hi-tech giant creates next generation of Edisons
- Couple's steamy romance e-books save their home
- David Coleman Headley: Terror sleeper agent foiled by NSA
- Innovative Ariz. class turns students' dreams into reality
- Two teens stranded 8,000 feet up on cliff rescued by chopper
- Couple reeling from recession rewrites story, publishes romance novels
- Officials say NSA programs stopped over 50 potential terror attacks
- SCOTUS: States can't require voters to prove citizenship; Couple reeling from recession publishes novels
- President Obama defends decisions on surveillance and Syria
- Ghost army: How a group of artists helped win WWII
- Iran's new president-elect seen as bridge-builder
- Colo. state senator faces recall after passage of gun control law
- Okla. tornado survivor finds dog buried alive under rubble
- Hi-tech giant spends millions to create next generation of Edisons
- Parents of mentally ill child may have averted mass shooting