January 12, 2012 7:14 PM

Nangalam: A symbol of the Afghan war's troubles

By
Clarissa Ward
(CBS News) 

Most Americans in Afghanistan are doing their best in a war that's now in its 11th year. Why has it taken this long?

CBS News correspondent Clarissa Ward found one reason in the Pech Valley. Americans lost their lives there building a base called Nangalam. When they tried to hand over their gains to the Afghan army, the base went to ruin.

This is one part of Afghanistan that America thought it could finally leave. But U.S. troops are back, trying once again to train their Afghan allies.

Army Major Guillermo Guillen, from Southern California, is frustrated.

"You're relying on us to do all your security for you. You need to be participating," Guillen told an Afghan counterpart.

On a recent patrol, some Afghan soldiers were not wearing helmets. One chatted on his cell phone.

"We're not going to be here forever, you need to take care of yourself," Guillen said.

The U.S. military left Nangalam base last February, handing over to Afghan forces. But within weeks, things went badly wrong.

Enemy forces returned to roam freely through the valley. The Afghan commander deserted. Hundreds of his soldiers followed.

"I believe there was some of (feeling of abandonment) amongst the (Afghan) soldiers. It's probably what led to some of their leadership leaving," Guillen said.

The Afghan forces that remained ransacked their own base.

All the electric wires have been pulled out. Anything of any value was taken. You can see the wiring hanging out of the light.

Just about everything else that could be moved was sold for cash.

Without American support, the Afghan army refused to resupply the base. The soldiers were living in filth.

For the U.S. military, it was an embarrassing example of what might happen when security is handed over to Afghan forces across the country, and so four months after leaving, a small group of U.S. troops was sent back in.

Today, American contractors are back on the base repairing the damage, with U.S. taxpayers footing the bill, again.

A new Afghan army unit has been brought in, with a new commander, Colonel Turab. U.S. officers have nicknamed him "Honest Abe."

And he was honest to a fault about the prospects for the Afghan army.

Nangalam, Afghanistan, troops

American and Afghan troops during a flag-lowering ceremony at Nangalam base in the Pech Valley in Afghanistan.

(Credit: CBS News)

"It will take about 30 years" for the Afghan army to be ready, Turab said through a translator. "And if they are reformed and the corruption is removed, ten years."

"They understand what they're doing. They understand what's required. It's just getting them to do it without coalition support," Guillen said.

The U.S. exit strategy depends on them doing it without support. Not in 30 years, and not in ten. They have just two years before the vast majority of American forces are scheduled to leave the Pech Valley - and all of Afghanistan - for good.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
Add a Comment See all 29 Comments
by Weallhaveone January 13, 2012 8:58 AM EST
Well there goes a lot of money for what was it again, right so Mr. Bush Jr. could feel good about his profits. Enjoy the waste of money that will be required in the future.
Reply to this comment
by longtree-2009 January 13, 2012 7:44 AM EST
when bin laden was assassinated, the next day all american troops should have been pulled out of afghanistan. obama failed to do it. the one good thing, if there is such a thing, about this some 10+ year war is that it is an all volunteer military. individuals are making the choice by volunteering to die for afghans who apparently care nothing about their country and are more into tribal loyalites than anything else. obama is like the overall enabler.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas_TX January 13, 2012 9:12 AM EST
But the hundred thousands of "brown people" who died as a result of the invasions did not volunteer. Neither did the US tax payers who have to finance this madness.
by js555554 January 13, 2012 4:52 AM EST
It's not really a country. It's a collection of tribes that have been at war with each other for centuries. When there are not killing each other, the women work like dogs to keep their families going. The men sit a around and talk about tribal matters during the day. Stop to pray 5 times a day and beat the wife's for not working hard enough in the evenings. A simple life. No one is going to change that.
Reply to this comment
by nancy_naive January 13, 2012 3:20 AM EST
News Flash -- Pentagon releases story on Afghan incompetence to cover story of American contemptuousness.
Reply to this comment
by aghast101 January 13, 2012 6:02 AM EST
No Nancy-naive The two stories ran side by side. It's a valid picture of what really happens.
by nancy_naive January 13, 2012 6:15 AM EST
Today,... but not yesterday when the may-rine story broke...
by CWOODS8178 January 13, 2012 2:12 AM EST
THESE PEOPLE HAVE NO PRIDE IN THEIR COUNTRY
GET OUT NOW AND BRING OUR TROOPS HOME.
Reply to this comment
by nancy_naive January 13, 2012 3:15 AM EST
No, they have pride in their country. They have disdain for us.

These people have been at war for centuries, and they are still there, but their invaders have all died off.
by venusvegasvada January 13, 2012 1:49 AM EST
They won't be ready in 2 years.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas_TX January 13, 2012 9:15 AM EST
Ready for what? To fight against their brothers so the US can continue to occupy their country and dictate their policies?
If the US leave they will find a compromise.
by taxedmore January 12, 2012 11:47 PM EST
Karzai should be more worried about this than who is peeing on who.
Reply to this comment
by joesapper January 12, 2012 11:37 PM EST
job security for contractors and tax payers are paying for everything along with haliburton. the old saying is we can take a horse to water but we can not make him drink. we have tried to change many people inclucing the natives of north america, maybe we should face the fact that maybe people do not want to change under pressure.
Reply to this comment
by redbeachvn January 12, 2012 11:16 PM EST
So what else is new? Afghan War is Vietnam Part II. I've seen it happen there. Best thing is for us to leave ASAP. They never asked us to be there, at least the average poor Afghans.
Reply to this comment
by Samlv January 12, 2012 11:13 PM EST
America's Error is trying to save others from themselves.

Look carefully at the proposed changes to our military. We're NOT going to do anything like this again.
Reply to this comment
by nancy_naive January 13, 2012 3:16 AM EST
and that's a good thing.
See all 29 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook