November 4, 2011 7:04 PM

Tarra and Bella: Elephant loses man's best friend

By
Steve Hartman
(CBS News) 

HOHENWALD, Tenn. - In 2009, CBS News correspondent Steve Hartman introduced you to a couple of very unlikely friends who couldn't have been more different. But from the moment Tarra the elephant met Bella the dog, they were inseparable.

The Elephant Sanctuary south of Nashville is more than 2,000 acres of freedom for elephants. But for a resident named Tarra, there's not enough room in Tennessee to escape the bad news she got last week.

(Scroll down to watch the original videos)

"Certainly her whole demeanor changed," said Rob Atkinson, the sanctuary's CEO. "She became more reserved, quieter, she was depressed."

Pictures: Unlikely friendship of Tarra and Bella

Tarra displayed all the symptoms you'd expect to see in someone who lost a good friend - which is exactly what happened.

For nearly a decade, Tarra had been best friends with a dog named Bella, a mutt who wandered onto the sanctuary grounds and into the heart of the gentle giant. Tarra clearly loved her little dog and Bella obviously bonded right back.

Watch the original video

They were so close, in fact, that when Bella got injured a few years ago and had to spend three weeks recuperating in the sanctuary office, guess who held vigil the entire time? Twenty-two hundred acres to roam free, and Tarra just stood in the corner waiting. Home video of their reunion shows how inseparable they'd become and remained, right to the end.

Last week, sanctuary workers found Bella's body. By all indications she'd been attacked by coyotes. Whether Tarra witnessed it, tried to intervene or was too late - no one knows. All they do know is that where they found Bella is not where she was attacked.

"When I looked around and saw there was no signs of an attack here. No blood, no tuffs of hair, nothing," said director of elephant husbandry, Steve Smith. "And Tarra, on the underside of her trunk, had blood - as if she picked up the body.

Watch the second Tarra and Bella video

Tarra moved her?

"Tarra moved her," Smith said.

Steve's theory is Tarra carried Bella possibly a mile or more to bring her home.

Whether it really happened that way or not, no one doubts Tarra was that devoted.

"There's nothing we can do to take away her pain," said Atkinson. "The only ones who can help now are the elephants. And that is already happening."

Atkinson said the elephants are "stepping in and stepping up." He said they're spending more time with Tarra and being extra nice - making gestures like giving her a portion of their food.

Of course, anyone who's lost a dog knows you can't eat your way out of the grief - as much we might try -- but still nice to know at least Tarra's not alone in this.

It's also nice to see that compassion is much more than just human.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
Add a Comment See all 33 Comments
by jimedwards3 November 17, 2011 9:53 AM EST
Very moving and life affirming. So glad CBS News decided to air this. It's been clear that animal stories have been kind of abandoned on the Evening News since Mr. Pelley started. That's an editorial choice and I get it but Mr. Scheiffer always made room for stories like this and for good reason. They give us hope.
Reply to this comment
by mankind_devolving November 17, 2011 1:37 AM EST
Steve Hartman wrote "It's also nice to see that compassion is much more than just human." Deborah wrote "Carol Buckley, Tarra's longest human friend who rescued her and spent 35 years with her, is not being allowed to visit Tarra at her time of need." Steve Atkinsson stated "There's nothing we can do to take away her pain. The only ones who can help now are the elephants. And that is already happening."

Am I the only one who sees animals as far more caring and compassionate than than humans?
Reply to this comment
by pammyj1023 November 14, 2011 1:31 PM EST
This absolutely breaks my heart! I've always heard that elephants are so intelligent, yet we keep treating them like "animals". An elephant and a dog bonding is just so special and the grief the elephant feels is probably what any one of us would feel at losing our best friend or life partner.
Reply to this comment
by JustCody November 13, 2011 10:47 AM EST
Thank you Steve. I freelance for another news network and suggested doing a piece on this....Those who make the choices looked at me blankly, even after I refreshed their memories on the original story. I was very happy to see that there are news reports interested in doing stories that touch our hearts rather then make us angry and frustrated.
Reply to this comment
by DeborahEBlair November 7, 2011 1:14 PM EST
Tarra the Elephant just lost Bella - her beloved Labrador - but most people don't know that her human rescuer and friend of 35 plus years, founder of the Elephant Sanctuary and Reknown elephant expert was thrown out and barred from Tarra in a very hostile takeover of the non-profit she founded. In court the Elephant Sanctuary Board has claimed since 2010 that Elephants are "property" - "things" ...and thus Carol cannot have visitation rights . .. they have profited with big donations from all of the Bella and Tarra videos - but they did NOT tell the truth behind the facts that Tarra is being kept from her long term friend. PLEASE HELP:

Bella - the canine friend to Tarra the elephant has gone on to the Rainbow Bridge - BUT Tarra needs our help! Urgent!!! Carol Buckley, Tarra's longest human friend who rescued her and spent 35 years with her, is not being allowed to visit Tarra at her time of need. Please help by signing the petition - dropping the CEO a personal note - and posting the petition to your FB page and sending its URL to your e-mail contacts - the direct address for the petition is: http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Unite-Tarra-the-Elephant-with-Carol-Buckley Email a personal note demanding that the Board of directors unite Carol and Tarra - CEO Rob Atkinson at elephant@elephants.com
Reply to this comment
by alyse928 November 7, 2011 2:18 PM EST
Thank you so much for posting this....most people don't know that Carol Buckley, Tarra's long time friend, and also founder of the The Elephant Sanctuary, was thrown out and barred from seeing Tarra last year. Thus, Tarra has not only lost her good friend Bella the dog, but she has also her human companion, Carol, of 35 years!!!!
by NorthrupP61 November 6, 2011 2:51 PM EST
Too many people think that animals have no finer feelings, even thogh we have so many examples of them caring about and caring for each other, from gorillas and elephants to vampire bats (reciprocal altruism). Humans aren't alone in this regard.
Reply to this comment
by sickofbull November 6, 2011 12:40 PM EST
Oh my goodness, this is so sad! The Tarra and Bella friendship was so special! What is not special is how opportunists seem to want to bash the Elephant Sanctuary no matter what they do. This Carol Buckley person is gone and has been for a couple of years now, and yet interested donors HAVE to see and listen to her mean camp of bullies rain BS at every chance. Rest in peace, Bella dog! There are still LOTS of us donors who think the dismissal was the best thing that could have happened. Let the courts decide. Certainly does not look good for CB is this is the type of support she has.
Reply to this comment
by LostandFond November 6, 2011 5:00 AM EST
I just read and reviewed a new book called Animal Grief - How Animals Mourn and that had some amazing stuff in I didn't know about how elephants behave when they lose someone close to them and this story just provides more evidence. So sad. I don't know the background to what has gone on at the sanctuary. It does sound very sad.
Reply to this comment
by bridger82923 November 6, 2011 10:29 AM EST
If you are on Face Book look for the Carol Buckley spporters group...what has happened to the sanctuary is criminal
by Imthaid2 November 5, 2011 2:01 PM EDT
"Atkinson said the elephants are "stepping in and stepping up." He said they're spending more time with Tarra and being extra nice - making gestures like giving her a portion of their food."

Too bad humans are not this nice.
Reply to this comment
by ToolMangler1 November 5, 2011 4:15 PM EDT
You must live in a cave.. All of my neighbors carry food and comfort to each other in a time of need or sorrow. You really need to get out more...
by drgoodie November 6, 2011 1:42 PM EST
I hope you meant "too bad SOME humans are not this nice". If not, you have little awareness of the extent of human compassion. If you search google and yahoo, you will find 90 pages and 80 pages respectively on "showing compassion." It is quite a theme amongst humanity and is considered an innate trait. I hope you find many expressions of it in your life, and also find ways to express it often.
by democracy8 November 5, 2011 11:54 AM EDT
I'd like to recommend an excellent book, "When Elephants Weep: The Emotional Lives of Animals" by Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson & Susan McCarthy.
Reply to this comment
See all 33 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook